CLAMP's Famous Works > Cardcaptor Sakura
Sakura's Feelings: Anime vs. Manga *Warning May Contain Spoilers*
aishiteru:
movie 2 was good and all, honestly. but i would have preferred the anime as it was in the manga when syaoran came back after a year with the bear. i only think this way because the ending of movie 2 was cute and all but it was just left as a cliffhanger because you could only believe what happened in the end, the predictable part. but think about it..
didn't syaoran come back to japan only to visit? wouldn't syaoran have to go back to china since he was only a 6th grader at the time? would he move back to japan? would they be together FOREVER? i mean, the ending is open to a lot of ideas that could possibly happen.
i seriously believe that sakura should have said her feelings in the anime rather than in the movie. but that's only my opinion. or better yet, they should have followed the way the love story unfolded in the manga when they were creating the anime. i think we all would have been like.. more into it if it unfolded like it did in the manga.
moezychan:
--- Quote from: aishiteru on February 28 2006, 04:42 am ---movie 2 was good and all, honestly. but i would have preferred the anime as it was in the manga when syaoran came back after a year with the bear. i only think this way because the ending of movie 2 was cute and all but it was just left as a cliffhanger because you could only believe what happened in the end, the predictable part. but think about it..
didn't syaoran come back to japan only to visit? wouldn't syaoran have to go back to china since he was only a 6th grader at the time? would he move back to japan? would they be together FOREVER? i mean, the ending is open to a lot of ideas that could possibly happen.
i seriously believe that sakura should have said her feelings in the anime rather than in the movie. but that's only my opinion. or better yet, they should have followed the way the love story unfolded in the manga when they were creating the anime. i think we all would have been like.. more into it if it unfolded like it did in the manga.
--- End quote ---
I'll agree with this. Between the anime and the manga I prefer the anime more, but I wish the anime would have ended like the manga. The manga gave a final ending. There was nothing to guess about, but the anime left an ending that makes it hard to interpret what happens. I need finality and the second movie didn't give me the finality I needed.
Hypercrabby:
Yeah, having the final moment in the anime be Sakura in midar just isn't as fufilling as her nestled in Syaoran's arms. It doesn't give you the same warmth inside as the manga did. I guess that is was agreed in advance to make two movies and the only way people would wanna watch is with a cliffhanger like that. Still, it's rather a cheap way to end a 3-season series! They gotta give the fans something.
I wonder what the 2nd movie would have been like if they had wrapped it up in the end of the series.
aishiteru:
--- Quote from: Hypercrabby on February 28 2006, 04:54 am ---I wonder what the 2nd movie would have been like if they had wrapped it up in the end of the series.
--- End quote ---
i bet a lot more people would have liked the second movie better if it didn't have such a broad ending. i mean, your mind can go in any direction with the ending of the second movie. with the ending of the manga, sakura says her feelings, syaoran leaves, they keep in contact with each other for a year, and he comes back to stay forever. it was pretty straight forward but it explained everything unlike how they ended the ccs series with the second movie.
Shiunu:
I agree with you guys. I haven't read the manga, but it did seem like Sakura was a little rushed when she found out that Syaoran loved her. She kinda had to decide quick, but in the end I think that help her realize that she had loved him all along. I think that's kinda neat because even though she didn't know it, she loved him the whole time. Sure, she could have said she loved him like in the manga at the end. I think personally that would kind of been neat to see in the anime actually. But of course there wouldn't have been those oh so cute awkward movie 2 moments that we adore. ^^
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version