Topic: S+S or F+K? (Read 249669 times)

suu_no_clover · « **Reply #520 on:** August 25 2006, 10:39 am »

I have no idea how or why you're drawing some of those conclusions, Tatasenko. How do we know their personalities are exactly the same? Who says one of them shouldn't exist!? D: And who said Real!Syaoran was ever meant to exist in Clow Country? o.O;

Err... on topic, on topic..... Go S+S?

Cherry tiger · « **Reply #521 on:** August 25 2006, 11:46 am »

Quote from: Tatasenko on August 25 2006, 06:58 am

Real Shaolan and Clone Shaolan share the same personnality,the only difference between them is their past .
so the two Shaolans have to both love Sakura,the only problem is that one of the two shoudn't exist !
they came from the same dimension,but the natural Shaolan has been replaced by a creation of Fei Wong Reed,so Sakura didn't meet her logical soulmate

remenber Sorata and Arashi,whatever their dimensions,their lives or their kind of relationship,they always ended up together,which means that even if chance has separated Sakura and Real Shaolan for a long time,Fate finally brought them together

What makes you so sure that Real Syaoran belongs to this Sakura? There's a chance that he might belong to another dimension and has another Sakura there...

Sakura didn't meet her logical soulmate? I believe she really did fall for Clow/Clone Syaoran... He did not have a very strong personality when Sakura found him, she brought that out of him and because of that she fell in love with him. If that's not enough (and I'll mention this a billion times if I have to) Sakura asked Real Syaoran to not kill Clow Syaoran and also begged the clone not to go... which means she knew that's her Syaoran that's leaving... There is no strong proof that Real Syaoran was truly meant for Sakura. At least not as of yet...

My passion for S+S continues to shine... Lol!!!

Hokuto · « **Reply #522 on:** August 25 2006, 02:02 pm »

Neither of the Syaoran's right now is Sakura's. NEITHER. Not the clone, not the Real. They're different.. the one she loves is Clow Syaoran. I don't know where he is... but I think he's dead.

That's what I think...

I like KuroxFay because SxS is pretty obvious because what Yukito said.

Cherry tiger · « **Reply #523 on:** August 25 2006, 04:03 pm »

Quote from: Hokuto on August 25 2006, 02:02 pm

Neither of the Syaoran's right now is Sakura's. NEITHER. Not the clone, not the Real. They're different.. the one she loves is Clow Syaoran. I don't know where he is... but I think he's dead.

That's what I think...

I like KuroxFay because SxS is pretty obvious because what Yukito said.

I actually don't understand what you mean... Are you saying that both Syaorans don't love Sakura yet Sakura only loves Clow Syaoran? @___@

Zettai daijoubu · « **Reply #524 on:** August 25 2006, 04:39 pm »

I like Cherry Tiger's opinion that Real!Syaoran might be destined for another Sakura in another dimension (mayb the CCS Sakura!!).. in that way, it'll be a happy ending for all Syaoran.. Sakura doesn't have memories of Clow Syaoran how would you know that she only loves him? The feelings for him might be only out of gratitude.. Since now that Real! Syaoran is travelling with them.. who knows she might fall for him..

for me.. I love Syaoran all the same.. Especially the clone one ^^

nefadol · « **Reply #525 on:** August 25 2006, 05:24 pm »

Quote from: Zettai daijoubu on August 25 2006, 04:39 pm

Sakura doesn't have memories of Clow Syaoran how would you know that she only loves him? The feelings for him might be only out of gratitude.. Since now that Real! Syaoran is travelling with them.. who knows she might fall for him.

Don't know about love (she hasn't said it....without her memories of him), but he is her "most precious person".Â When Subaru was trying to wake her up, he said "Wake up.Â If you don't open your eyes, your precious person will not return." (how did Subaru know that?).Â All the people important to her flashed and the last one was Syaoran, which she said "My precious person...precious...Syaoran-kun".

She had just realized that he was the most important person to her right when she woke up, which made what happened afterwards far more painful from my perspective.

Capella · « **Reply #526 on:** August 25 2006, 08:30 pm »

"Most precious person" is usually CLAMP code for love, so I'd say Sakura definitely loved clone!Syaoran before he lost his heart (I think what Tatasenko meant was that neither of the Syaorans we have now - Real or Soulless Clone - is in love with Sakura). I also believe that Sakura won't end up with real!Syaoran, because he is not her Syaoran even if he is the original. As he said, the clone's love for Sakura was not his emotion, but the clone's own. So our hope for SyaoSaku is that somehow clone!Syaoran gets back to how he was before. I like the theory that Sakura's ability to speak to things that aren't human or even alive will help her reach out to him.

SyaoSaku is so much more fun now that we having weird stuff like this.

Celestial · « **Reply #527 on:** August 25 2006, 08:58 pm »

Clamp is showing growth in role reversal. Sakura lost her emotions, now Shaoran has lost his (i think??? i dont read the manga). Maby the fact they have both lost them, will be like a reset in the relationship, since they did fall in love naturaly, why couldnt it happen agin XD

Cherry tiger · « **Reply #528 on:** August 25 2006, 11:45 pm »

Ah... that's true. Sakura does have the ability to hear things that cannot be heard... maybe she's able to her Clow Syaoran's voice then? Hmm...

Sakura lost her memories, not her emotions... after all, she did develop her feelings for Clow Syaoran all over again, though it isn't the same. Now Clone Syaoran has no emotions... and whether or not this clone programming will disappear and Clow Syaoran will resurface is another thought... >_>

Zettai daijoubu · « **Reply #529 on:** August 26 2006, 12:02 am »

Maybe Clow Syaoran's heart is just asleep within the Clone Syaoran.. he sorta have split personality right? one good and one evil..

and yea SakuSyao is soooo fun now that we hav TWO Syaorans..

Hokuto · « **Reply #530 on:** August 26 2006, 12:41 am »

Quote from: Cherry tiger on August 25 2006, 04:03 pm

I actually don't understand what you mean... Are you saying that both Syaorans don't love Sakura yet Sakura only loves Clow Syaoran? @___@

Yes Cherry Tiger. XDD Lol I know you from somewhere.... O.O

Cherry tiger · « **Reply #531 on:** August 26 2006, 12:47 am »

When you mean both... do you mean Clone and Real Syaoran and not 'Our' Syaoran or the Syaoran we knew throughout Tsubasa? Cause I'm sure he loved Sakura... @__@

Lol! You know me? I wonder where... could it be in the Tsubasa forums?

Hokuto · « **Reply #532 on:** August 26 2006, 12:51 am »

Yes I mean that Clone and Real isn't her Syaoran.
- Clone's heart got taken away. He only cares about the feathers since the beginning never Sakura.
-The real Syaoran said he doesn't care about Sakura

So.... where did those feelings come from? Clow Syaoran? XD

Yeah yeah!! Tsubasa Fourms! Ppppst me Tsubasa Yuuko XD

Cherry tiger · « **Reply #533 on:** August 26 2006, 02:04 am »

The Real Syaoran didn't really say he doesn't care about Sakura, did he? The latest chapter showed that he did... but whether he loves Sakura is still unknown. So I think the right word to look for is Real Syaoran doesn't love Sakura... or at least, there's no proof of it yet.

Yeah, I call him Clow Syaoran, or to some people, our Syaoran because he's the one whom we've seen and known throughout the whole series so far...

I knew it was you! You have those cute icons in your signature and I knew you came from the Tsubasa forums. ^^

nefadol · « **Reply #534 on:** August 26 2006, 05:06 am »

Quote from: Capella on August 25 2006, 08:30 pm

"Most precious person" is usually CLAMP code for love, so I'd say Sakura definitely loved clone!Syaoran before he lost his heart (I think what Tatasenko meant was that neither of the Syaorans we have now - Real or Soulless Clone - is in love with Sakura).

Oh, I know it means love.Â It's just that quite a few people only acknowledge it if it's bluntly stated that they "love" them, sadly.

The whole incident reminds me of what happened to Subaru in Tokyo Babylon though.Â The second he figures out that he loves Seishirou...BAM...finds out he's not who he thought he was.Â I think Sakura can love the clone regardless if his heart comes back or not (which I think it will), which leads me back to Subaru.Â After what Seishirou did (which is far worse than what C!Syaoran did), he still loved him and couldn't erase him from his heart.

Sakura and Subaru are very similar in a lot of ways, and I think that their hearts are also similar.Â She'll love C!Syaoran despite what he does or becomes, she's incapable of hate.Â Although I'd definately prefer for him to revert back to his old kind self and be with her, Sakura with a mindless killing machine doesn't sound right.

Tatasenko · « **Reply #535 on:** August 26 2006, 06:46 am »

like Yuuko said there is no way for Clone Shaolan to get back his heart since the seal has been broken...but she has the odd habit to never reveal all she knows at one time,in order to always let people decide by their own reflexion what they should do

(for instance she didn"t tell to Kurogane that the blood bond with Fai was reversible,in order to not influence his mind

).

so it is possible that there is in fact a way to save Clone Shaolan,but she doesn't want to unveil now the solution because she wishes to see first how the new group is going to advance without him,and she is certainly curious to discover what will be the type of relationship between Sakura and Real Shaolan

Cherry tiger · « **Reply #536 on:** August 26 2006, 01:01 pm »

That's definitely possible... maybe even Sakura will be the one to reach out to Clone Syaoran... who knows? All I know is that Sakura really did love Clow/Clone Syaoran... That's why I get a little iffed when people say Sakura should go with Real Syaoran and Clone Syaoran should die. >__<

Zettai daijoubu · « **Reply #537 on:** August 26 2006, 03:58 pm »

Clone Syaoran cannot die!!!! *screams*

after so much fluff we of course hope that Our Syaoran can some day come back.. probably with a bit of clone Syaoran's personality so that he isn't that prefect.. >.<

Cherry tiger · « **Reply #538 on:** August 27 2006, 12:58 am »

Does Clone Syaoran even have a personality? Lol! All he cares about is getting Sakura's feathers. Maybe his coldness? The distance? But... kyaa... I don't want him to distance himself from Sakura. >__<

Rekall · « **Reply #539 on:** August 27 2006, 02:30 am »

*breaks into the convo and points at the poll*

Only 9 votes behind! I don't think it's ever been that close before! I'm glad people are starting to like them. ^__^

News:

Poll

Another popularity contest between the two most popular couple of TRC.

AuthorTopic: S+S or F+K? (Read 249669 times)