CLAMP's Famous Works > Tsubasa RESERVoir CHRoNiCLE
TRC: Anime vs. Manga
Hack:
manga of course, it's more detailed
moezychan:
--- Quote from: Jeannette on July 30 2006, 12:39 pm ---XD Is there any reason to ask? Does ANYONE prefer the anime? Seriously, though. I almost never prefer the anime over the manga, but I feel this way far more towards Tsubasa and HOLiC. (About the only series where I prefer the anime is Revolutionary Girl Utena... the manga s*cks badly.) As beautiful as the music and VAs are, the animation and adapation are usually awful. I'll continue to watch and even buy it unless it goes even more downhill, just for the very well done parts, but I will always prefer the manga.
--- End quote ---
I'll admit the poll might have been a bit out of place, but my main goal here, as stated, was so we could dicuss rationally. I've seen a lot of members on the forums say that the anime isn't bad, but don't bother to back up why it isn't bad. I wanted people to state reasons. That was my true goal.
Rekall:
--- Quote from: Jeannette on July 30 2006, 12:39 pm ---XD Is there any reason to ask? Does ANYONE prefer the anime? Seriously, though. I almost never prefer the anime over the manga
--- End quote ---
Ditto. It's extremely rare for me to watch an anime after I've read the manga anymore because I always end up disappointed that the anime version isn't as good as the manga.
The only times I perfer anime over manga is when the series is based off of something else. For example Kyou Kara Maou is based off of novels and even though there is now both an anime and a manga I like the anime better (although the manga is also fairly good). Miene Liebe is another example except it was a video game first instead of a novel (the ML manga is really bad compared to the anime and CD dramas).
Airashii:
Whoa, it seems that nobody likes the anime...wonder why, BeeTrain?
Anyway, the manga is soooo much better. The detail, their emotions, the funny faces Fai and Kurogane make, it's all unique in the manga. More funny and more violence...hehehehe...^o^.
Capella:
I voted for the manga, obviously, but everyone has explained the reasons already so I don't feel the need to elaborate. I love the anime music, and there are certain parts I like (Outo and Shara/Shura), but overall there really is no comparison. It doesn't help that I prefer manga to anime as a medium in the first place (I just would rather read, and read over and over again than watch something on a screen).
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version