CLAMP's Famous Works > Tsubasa RESERVoir CHRoNiCLE
TRC: Anime vs. Manga
TrC_ChRiStI*:
--- Quote from: Møon Li on August 12 2006, 01:35 pm ---I like both... though I would prefer that every detail and the story, was the same way... I mean no changes betwen them.
--- End quote ---
hahaha i think both, too but in the other hand the manga is more complete and u can underestand it better , but the anime is more realistic because the caracters are like interesting xD
Tatasenko:
CLAMP's work can never be equalled by their anime counterpart because there are so many details in the manga that it would be impossible to convey everything on tv support,the productors are forced to do a compression,and it works more or less :sweatdrop:
suzine:
--- Quote from: Tatasenko on August 15 2006, 09:51 am ---CLAMP's work can never be equalled by their anime counterpart because there are so many details in the manga that it would be impossible to convey everything on tv support,the productors are forced to do a compression,and it works more or less :sweatdrop:
--- End quote ---
Heh. It works as "less" in the X TV anime (24 chapters for the whole X storyline+ the tacked-on ending. "Condensed" doesn't begin to cover it).
Voted for the manga, too. While the anime has beautiful music, the manga's far more complex and interesting, IMO.
Plus, BeeTrain, WTF?
1) Baaad fillers, no cookie! If CCS, DBZ and Inuyasha can manage good (and occasionally great) fillers, than so can you! Put a bit of effort into it, willya?
2)Â Really, most people aren't that stupid. And anime appeals to people older then 10. You can show blood, drinking and all if it's relevent to the plot or amusing.
Syaozen:
Manga all the waaay.
Emotions are horribly done in the anime, as with action sequences which are usually one image slightly moving, lol. Most of all, hardly any blood.
Not that I wanna see Syaoran get all bloody or anything, but it just makes the series seem a lot more serious than the anime makes it.
It's also really monotone and that makes it pathetic, really pathetic. I hate Syaoran's voice actor as well. The first episode where he was like crying for help, it was like he wasn't even putting any emotion in it as for the manga it was one of the important scenes of how determined he was.
I hate Bee Train. Period.
I agree, no animator can match CLAMP's beautiful artwork. I witnessed it in front of eyes in AX2006, when meeting them for the autograph. But C'MON, BEE TRAIN?? Ugh. If CLAMP is gonna do a series involving all of their past works into one, it has to be CLAMP that helps animate it and direct it, not freakin Bee Train.
Anyway, I thought CCS went magnificiently well even on its own storyline. I would love to have those animators do tsubasa, but I guess it's too late. The only thing that'd make me happy from the tsubasa anime is if they make like, the other Syaoran with the CCS Syaoran's voice. Then maybe my love for the series will finally kick in for the anime as well. I can't even imagine how they're gonna pull one of Syaoran's incantations with the current seiyuu.
Tatasenko:
the only thing that is really worthy in the anime are the music,which are totally wonderful,a true opera :okay:
moreover they always match perfectly with the actions,so it helps us bear the mediocre quality of the animation :keke:
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version