Topic: TRC: Anime vs. Manga (Read 19811 times)

~Bloody_Rose~ · « **Reply #40 on:** September 21 2006, 05:48 pm »

well, i like the manga more than the anime.. coz of BeeTrain murdering the anime, the story's plot is ugh!!!

Little Wolf · « **Reply #41 on:** September 21 2006, 11:12 pm »

Where did that one vote for the anime came from? Seriously?!?

~Bloody_Rose~ · « **Reply #42 on:** September 23 2006, 02:16 pm »

Quote from: Little Wolf on September 21 2006, 11:12 pm

Where did that one vote for the anime came from? Seriously?!?

our beloved admin, maybe, the user has watched the first few episodes of TRC and havent' watch it for a long time...

tsuki · « **Reply #43 on:** September 24 2006, 08:08 am »

i said both are best!! ^__^
coz anime=has wonderful OST,their voices,songs,ans the diffferences from the manga.
coz manga=it is usually faster(the story)than anime,can read many times,and omakes!!(extras)
thats why i said both! ^__^

charcoalz · « **Reply #44 on:** September 25 2006, 02:18 pm »

hehe, i like the manga more..it has more detail =)

suu_no_clover · « **Reply #45 on:** September 25 2006, 02:25 pm »

Regardless of the pwnage of the music of the anime, it's still not good enough to save it from the animation of the anime. :/

Chibi · « **Reply #46 on:** September 29 2006, 12:46 pm »

The manga of course.

The anime had a lot of potential, but Bee Train just ruined it. I really liked season 1, but season 2... oh, what happened to you? First of all, I was kind of mad with them switching the worlds around, since Piffle came after the Shura world in the manga, but whatever. But what really made me mad is how they're just rushing through the canon worlds. I expected waaaay more than 3 episodes for Piffle, and more for Shura. *sigh*

The fillers, oh don't get me started. Okay, I loved the one where they were all drawn by Mokona. Best. Filler. EVER. That's Tsubasa on CRACK. However, the fillers this season have been horrible. I didn't really mind the ones last season, but...

The one with the bus. That was a total waste of my life. The majority of the episodes was them sitting on the bus and Bee Train abusing that beautiful song.

The FaixChii episode... oh, don't get me started. Chii's not a human. In Tsubasa, she's an alarm system. In Chobits, she's a persocom. WHY IS SHE A HUMAN NOW?! And what about HIDEKI?!?! Hideki is Chii's one and only! Not Fai! Fai wasn't in Chobits!

Eh, I need to get off to study for a test, but I'm sure everyone else can explain what else I don't like with the anime. ^^

*~LostKitty~* · « **Reply #47 on:** September 29 2006, 12:53 pm »

I like BOTH !!!
I can't really decide cause both the anome and manga are greaat

SOxxYOUxxTHOUGHT · « **Reply #48 on:** September 29 2006, 01:14 pm »

i think the manga is better, because it(artwork, storyline, etc.) actually is what the author/artist wants.

but don't get me wrong, the anime is still great. it's just that sometimes, when it's animated...it can get....disappointing. ^^"

Toge-chan · « **Reply #49 on:** October 04 2006, 10:23 am »

I like the manga best. It's somehow more detailed and relaxed as in the number of chapters in a world, compared to the number of episodes in a world.

The music mostly owns. But the animÃ© itself was ruined by BeeTrain, the animation and all the censoring is like, annoying. After all, it's really childish that just like that. In this kind of things there's violence, and it's stupid not to show one or two blind eyes, also changing everything in Chun-Hyang's world for political issues is racist. . . in my opinion.

But yeah, manga for me~

Moro-dashi · « **Reply #50 on:** October 04 2006, 11:28 am »

Manga manga manga manga manga manga manga. Which means alot coming from me, because I have ADHD and it's hard for me to sit and read for an extended period of time XD Especially when I'm reading the scanalations, and I am doing 100 things at once on the computer so it takes me an hour or so to read one chapter.

I swear if theres much more KuroTomoness I'm going to puke. It's just about the worst thing since DIC made Zoicite a female in Sailor Moon o_O. If they totally disregard KuroFai (There have still been some strong KuroFai momments in the anime, IMHO), I'll kill a man. Or several.

The anime is not without it's merrit though. Like someone said, the Oekaki Mokona episode XD "GAO!!!!!!!!!! BEEEEAM!!!" ::Rolls.:: Also, I'm working on my KuroFai AMV right now, and I just rewatched the scene in Season 1 Ep 17 where Fai forcefeeds Kuro the chocolate, and the sounds he makes while he's poking him are priceless XD. I think we all agree that the vocie actors rock.

There are a *few* filler scenes that have been worth it. LIke in the bus episode, watching Kuro trying to make small talk with that old man was priceless. However, it seems for ever cute filler scene theres like, 10 amazing scenes from the manga that are left out T_T I was so excited about seeing Fai and Sakura drunk and Kuro chasing them around. Oh well. :/

Ruby Chan · « **Reply #51 on:** October 05 2006, 08:36 pm »

Definitely the manga. Bee Train has slaughtered the anime, especially the episode where Fai used his magic for the first time properly. And the fillers are driving me crazy - most of the time they don't even have relevant plots!

cameo · « **Reply #52 on:** October 12 2006, 11:55 am »

manga is my choice!!!!!!!!!!!!!... anime.. i watched the first season only. second season, i lost interest.

*~LostKitty~* · « **Reply #53 on:** October 27 2006, 07:20 pm »

I think both the anime and manga has its own "atractions''
ANIME : it has colour , sounds...the fighting techniques are cooler , the songs and background music are nice and also , it offers some episodes we don't find in the manga [ like the episode in season 2 which they all turn into chibi versions ]
MANGA : the art is great , neat and easy to read. The charcters are also more comical

Tatasenko · « **Reply #54 on:** November 05 2006, 09:06 am »

Quote from: lostkitty on October 27 2006, 07:20 pm

I think both the anime and manga has its own "atractions''
ANIME : it has colour , sounds...the fighting techniques are cooler , the songs and background music are nice and also , it offers some episodes we don't find in the manga [ like the episode in season 2 which they all turn into chibi versions ]
MANGA : the art is great , neat and easy to read. The charcters are also more comical

the problem of mostly anime is that in order to take advantage of huge amount of profits,the animation studios broadcast the first episodes while the mangas are still only few chapters further on,so they are forced to create useless episodes to keep up the distance with the manga

.
of course this quick procedure seems totally foolish since it only ends with a insipid anime,but if the studios want to earn much money they have to make advertisements and goodies since the beginning,even if it means sacrificing the quality of the anime for their own benefit

!

but this isn't an excuse for beetrain's botched work,because when we think about the wonderful anime of Full Metal Alchemist they are totally crushed :
the anime of FMA was started while the manga was near his end,and however it was a incredible success which has generated a historical outcome!and sicne Bones studio has waited to see the progress of the scenario in the manga they have got plenty time to do a meticulous work

!

FMA which wasn't a very popular manga has got a gorgeous anime,while TRC which comes from the widely-known CLAMP has got a ugly anime,money is not everything

Arcademan · « **Reply #55 on:** November 05 2006, 09:13 am »

The manga is much better than the anime...but then again, this can be said about almost any series that you compare the manga to their anime counterpart.

Tatasenko · « **Reply #56 on:** November 05 2006, 10:08 am »

Quote from: Arcademan on November 05 2006, 09:13 am

The manga is much better than the anime...but then again, this can be said about almost any series that you compare the manga to their anime counterpart.

yeah,this is certainly the way things should be

i think that it is natural to prefer manga to anime,it comes from the difference of feelings conveyed between the two supports !
flashy colors are fading the sinuous lines of a artwork,and a single symbolical image is often much more expressive than some awkwards action scenes

.

it's exactly the same thing as when we are looking at formers family photos in black and white,the emotions that occurs are always deeper than when we are watching photos in colors,mostly because in the first case the details become more pronounced

!

Sandra-chan · « **Reply #57 on:** November 05 2006, 10:42 am »

The manga is (of course) much better than the anime!!!, I can't belive some people think the anime is better....

Itzeen · « **Reply #58 on:** November 05 2006, 10:49 am »

Pros of the manga; the drowings are excuisit, a story with no censure, blood (well is like realistic).

Pros of the anime; You can see them in colour, with movement and voices, and intro and ending songs.

Neg of the manga; I think............... is in black and white..... I would like in colour

Neg of the anime; where can I start.... ok some filling episodes.... some times the adaptation of the manga version, and many other things, but I'm lazy to write them all.

Sandra-chan · « **Reply #59 on:** November 05 2006, 10:55 am »

Quote from: Tatasenko on November 05 2006, 09:06 am

the problem of mostly anime is that in order to take advantage of huge amount of profits,the animation studios broadcast the first episodes while the mangas are still only few chapters further on,so they are forced to create useless episodes to keep up the distance with the manga .
of course this quick procedure seems totally foolish since it only ends with a insipid anime,but if the studios want to earn much money they have to make advertisements and goodies since the beginning,even if it means sacrificing the quality of the anime for their own benefit !

but this isn't an excuse for beetrain's botched work,because when we think about the wonderful anime of Full Metal Alchemist they are totally crushed :
the anime of FMA was started while the manga was near his end,and however it was a incredible success which has generated a historical outcome!and sicne Bones studio has waited to see the progress of the scenario in the manga they have got plenty time to do a meticulous work !

FMA which wasn't a very popular manga has got a gorgeous anime,while TRC which comes from the widely-known CLAMP has got a ugly anime,money is not everything

Well I just wanted to say that I also love the FMA anime very much, but the anime wasn't made when the manga was near it's end. It was made 2004 and the manga is still ongoing.

And because the manga wasn't finished bones made up the ending for the series. I agree on that the FMA anime might be more popular than the manga but the manga is very famous too!

News:

Poll

Which is better?

AuthorTopic: TRC: Anime vs. Manga (Read 19811 times)