CLAMP's Famous Works > Tsubasa RESERVoir CHRoNiCLE
TRC: Anime vs. Manga
Arcademan:
The manga is much better than the anime...but then again, this can be said about almost any series that you compare the manga to their anime counterpart.
Tatasenko:
--- Quote from: Arcademan on November 05 2006, 09:13 am ---The manga is much better than the anime...but then again, this can be said about almost any series that you compare the manga to their anime counterpart.
--- End quote ---
yeah,this is certainly the way things should be :keke:
i think that it is natural to prefer manga to anime,it comes from the difference of feelings conveyed between the two supports !
flashy colors are fading the sinuous lines of a artwork,and a single symbolical image is often much more expressive than some awkwards action scenes :surprised:.
it's exactly the same thing as when we are looking at formers family photos in black and white,the emotions that occurs are always deeper than when we are watching photos in colors,mostly because in the first case the details become more pronounced :okay:!
Sandra-chan:
The manga is (of course) much better than the anime!!!, I can't belive some people think the anime is better....
Itzeen:
Pros of the manga; the drowings are excuisit, a story with no censure, blood (well is like realistic).
Pros of the anime; You can see them in colour, with movement and voices, and intro and ending songs.
Neg of the manga; I think............... is in black and white..... I would like in colour
Neg of the anime; where can I start.... ok some filling episodes.... some times the adaptation of the manga version, and many other things, but I'm lazy to write them all.
Sandra-chan:
--- Quote from: Tatasenko on November 05 2006, 09:06 am ---the problem of mostly anime is that in order to take advantage of huge amount of profits,the animation studios broadcast the first episodes while the mangas are still only few chapters further on,so they are forced to create useless episodes to keep up the distance with the manga :dodge:.
of course this quick procedure seems totally foolish since it only ends with a insipid anime,but if the studios want to earn much money they have to make advertisements and goodies since the beginning,even if it means sacrificing the quality of the anime for their own benefit :surprised:!
but this isn't an excuse for beetrain's botched work,because when we think about the wonderful anime of Full Metal Alchemist they are totally crushed :
the anime of FMA was started while the manga was near his end,and however it was a incredible success which has generated a historical outcome!and sicne Bones studio has waited to see the progress of the scenario in the manga they have got plenty time to do a meticulous work :okay:!
FMA which wasn't a very popular manga has got a gorgeous anime,while TRC which comes from the widely-known CLAMP has got a ugly anime,money is not everything :shifty:
--- End quote ---
Well I just wanted to say that I also love the FMA anime very much, but the anime wasn't made when the manga was near it's end. It was made 2004 and the manga is still ongoing. :sweatdrop: And because the manga wasn't finished bones made up the ending for the series. I agree on that the FMA anime might be more popular than the manga but the manga is very famous too! :okay:
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version