Poll

Which is better?

Tsubasa Anime
Tsubasa Manga
both
neither o_O

AuthorTopic: TRC: Anime vs. Manga  (Read 19818 times)

0 Members and 6 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline Hack

  • LuckyStar
  • Dedicated Fan
  • ****
  • Posts: 923
  • Gender: Female
Re: TRC: Anime vs. Manga
« Reply #20 on: July 30 2006, 12:56 pm »
manga of course, it's more detailed
by me.

moezychan

  • Guest
Re: TRC: Anime vs. Manga
« Reply #21 on: July 30 2006, 01:06 pm »
XD Is there any reason to ask? Does ANYONE prefer the anime? Seriously, though. I almost never prefer the anime over the manga, but I feel this way far more towards Tsubasa and HOLiC. (About the only series where I prefer the anime is Revolutionary Girl Utena... the manga s*cks badly.) As beautiful as the music and VAs are, the animation and adapation are usually awful. I'll continue to watch and even buy it unless it goes even more downhill, just for the very well done parts, but I will always prefer the manga.

I'll admit the poll might have been a bit out of place, but my main goal here, as stated, was so we could dicuss rationally. I've seen a lot of members on the forums say that the anime isn't bad, but don't bother to back up why it isn't bad. I wanted people to state reasons. That was my true goal.

Offline Rekall

  • It's spelled C.A.N.O.N
  • Super Fan
  • ***
  • Posts: 391
  • Gender: Female
  • made by evercool on LJ
Re: TRC: Anime vs. Manga
« Reply #22 on: July 30 2006, 01:55 pm »
XD Is there any reason to ask? Does ANYONE prefer the anime? Seriously, though. I almost never prefer the anime over the manga

Ditto.  It's extremely rare for me to watch an anime after I've read the manga anymore because I always end up disappointed that the anime version isn't as good as the manga.

The only times I perfer anime over manga is when the series is based off of something else.  For example Kyou Kara Maou is based off of novels and even though there is now both an anime and a manga I like the anime better (although the manga is also fairly good).  Miene Liebe is another example except it was a video game first instead of a novel (the ML manga is really bad compared to the anime and CD dramas).
LiveJournal - RG Veda LJ Community - Fanfiction.net Account - Ficwad Account

Proud Member of The "Remember Hideki" Campaign

Offline Airashii

  • I Will Fight For My Love!
  • cRAzY fan
  • ****
  • Posts: 666
  • Gender: Female
  • Gay is Happy
Re: TRC: Anime vs. Manga
« Reply #23 on: July 31 2006, 11:19 am »
Whoa, it seems that nobody likes the anime...wonder why, BeeTrain?

Anyway, the manga is soooo much better. The detail, their emotions, the funny faces Fai and Kurogane make, it's all unique in the manga. More funny and more violence...hehehehe...^o^.

Embrace and kiss me
My feelings of falling in love with you is never ending
'Aikoi' by FictionJunction YUUKA
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Forum Family My cool little bro: Kouichi

Offline Capella

  • The Ashura family owns my soul
  • Obsessed Fan
  • ***
  • Posts: 485
  • Gender: Female
  • Anti-God - Ashura
Re: TRC: Anime vs. Manga
« Reply #24 on: July 31 2006, 11:24 am »
I voted for the manga, obviously, but everyone has explained the reasons already so I don't feel the need to elaborate. I love the anime music, and there are certain parts I like (Outo and Shara/Shura), but overall there really is no comparison. It doesn't help that I prefer manga to anime as a medium in the first place (I just would rather read, and read over and over again than watch something on a screen).
The  "Remember Hideki" Campaign: Chii's one and only "someone just for me."
Come here to join!

My Forum Family
Elder Sister = Jeannette
Cousin = Becster


Offline tidus_oz

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 8
  • Gender: Male
  • Personal text here! Edit this on your profile page.
Re: TRC: Anime vs. Manga
« Reply #25 on: August 06 2006, 01:26 pm »
I voted for manga definitely, but the anime have a lot of good music in it. But the storyline progress in  manga is fast and the story become more complicated. As expected from CLAMP :haha:

Offline xxxholic

  • Good Fan
  • **
  • Posts: 117
  • Gender: Female
  • Personal text here! Edit this on your profile page.
Re: TRC: Anime vs. Manga
« Reply #26 on: August 07 2006, 12:12 pm »
I prefer the anime, just like the rest of the people here. But i am surprised that there are no votes for the anime version of TRC. I totally blame that on BEETRAIN. They certainly did wrecked the whole series for me by editing tons of things that happened in the manga. And to think that they practically made Chii and Kuro canon almost made me freaked out. But i guess i was only looking too deep into things.

All in all, i agree with most of what has been said.

Offline xOLight_AngelOx

  • Obsessed Fan
  • ***
  • Posts: 437
Re: TRC: Anime vs. Manga
« Reply #27 on: August 07 2006, 01:50 pm »
well i like both and always have

Offline Chang

  • Dedicated Fan
  • ****
  • Posts: 863
  • Gender: Female
  • yat yan sei gaai bui
Re: TRC: Anime vs. Manga
« Reply #28 on: August 12 2006, 01:11 pm »
i like both coz they're equally good ^_^
I wonder what kind of fate awaits me?
I don't want to regret being born
There is courage inside my sadness
I believe I can grasp that radiance
The tears of the blue sky are pouring down
One day they'll change into smiles

Forum Family:
Tatasenko: my awesome sister ^_^

Offline Møon Li

  • Aishiteru SyaorAndru <3
  • cRAzY fan
  • ****
  • Posts: 737
  • Gender: Female
  • avatar colored by me ^o^
Re: TRC: Anime vs. Manga
« Reply #29 on: August 12 2006, 01:35 pm »
I like both... though I would prefer that every detail and the story, was the same way... I mean no changes betwen them.

When we love, we want to be better than we already are... and love makes us better"



♥ Syaoran Loves Me ♥

~*Forum Family*~
Daughters: Okamirei, Star Wings
Little sisters:pretty.sofiacardcaptors.babypigggy.TimeMachine.bie liao.charcoalz.kudan.Aya-Chan.Kairi.SailorYue.tsubasaHime199.EuphoriaBliss.nicole_shimun
Little brothers: 89757knight.Kouichi
Nieces: Moonflower121.hikari_blaze.Monse-chan.littlekitty
Cousins: Director of Music.aishiteru.

Møon LUNiTe CHRoNiCLE

Offline TrC_ChRiStI*

  • Big Fan
  • **
  • Posts: 189
  • Gender: Female
  • ~$~ý~à~ø~®~à~N~
Re: TRC: Anime vs. Manga
« Reply #30 on: August 15 2006, 09:29 am »
I like both... though I would prefer that every detail and the story, was the same way... I mean no changes betwen them.

hahaha i think both, too but in the other hand the manga is more complete and u can underestand it better , but the anime is more realistic because the caracters are like interesting xD

I know that our love cant fall

Offline Tatasenko

  • Fai is more than definitely French !
  • "Die-Hard Fan!"
  • *****
  • Posts: 1,576
  • Gender: Female
  • Personal text here! Edit this on your profile page.
Re: TRC: Anime vs. Manga
« Reply #31 on: August 15 2006, 09:51 am »
CLAMP's work can never be equalled by their anime counterpart because there are so many details in the manga that it would be impossible to convey everything on tv support,the productors are forced to do a compression,and it works more or less  :sweatdrop:


* "Mokona's kidnappers" guild * (http://www.capturedwings.net/forums/index.php?topic=3381.msg188911;topicseen#msg188911)
Team mate : Ishiyaki (journalist)
Subordinates : Sailor Yue Chan : Spy / Suu No Clover : Doctor / Airashii : Strategist / Kjesta : Factor

* Forum Family *
Ishiyaki : Team mate of the "Mokona's kidnappers" guild / Kina : Cookies shopkeeper / Nectar rain : The happy lucky cheerful girl / Airashii : banner's creator / SailorYue Chan : Twins / Moon Li : French counterpart / Kjesta : Soulmate / Znuese : Rainbow summoner and Brother

Offline suzine

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 14
  • Gender: Female
  • Personal text here! Edit this on your profile page.
Re: TRC: Anime vs. Manga
« Reply #32 on: August 16 2006, 07:07 am »
CLAMP's work can never be equalled by their anime counterpart because there are so many details in the manga that it would be impossible to convey everything on tv support,the productors are forced to do a compression,and it works more or less :sweatdrop:
Heh. It works as "less" in the X TV anime (24 chapters for the whole X storyline+ the tacked-on ending. "Condensed" doesn't begin to cover it).

Voted for the manga, too. While the anime has beautiful music, the manga's far more complex and interesting, IMO.

Plus, BeeTrain, WTF?
1) Baaad fillers, no cookie! If CCS, DBZ and Inuyasha can manage good (and occasionally great) fillers, than so can you! Put a bit of effort into it, willya?

2)  Really, most people aren't that stupid. And anime appeals to people older then 10. You can show blood, drinking and all if it's relevent to the plot or amusing.
If everybody minded their own business, the world would go around a deal faster.
-The Duchess, "Through the Looking Glass"

Offline Syaozen

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 41
  • Gender: Male
  • Raitei Shourai!
Re: TRC: Anime vs. Manga
« Reply #33 on: August 16 2006, 10:44 am »
Manga all the waaay.

Emotions are horribly done in the anime, as with action sequences which are usually one image slightly moving, lol. Most of all, hardly any blood.

Not that I wanna see Syaoran get all bloody or anything, but it just makes the series seem a lot more serious than the anime makes it.

It's also really monotone and that makes it pathetic, really pathetic. I hate Syaoran's voice actor as well. The first episode where he was like crying for help, it was like he wasn't even putting any emotion in it as for the manga it was one of the important scenes of how determined he was.

I hate Bee Train. Period.
I agree, no animator can match CLAMP's beautiful artwork. I witnessed it in front of eyes in AX2006, when meeting them for the autograph. But C'MON, BEE TRAIN?? Ugh. If CLAMP is gonna do a series involving all of their past works into one, it has to be CLAMP that helps animate it and direct it, not freakin Bee Train.

Anyway, I thought CCS went magnificiently well even on its own storyline. I would love to have those animators do tsubasa, but I guess it's too late. The only thing that'd make me happy from the tsubasa anime is if they make like, the other Syaoran with the CCS Syaoran's voice. Then maybe my love for the series will finally kick in for the anime as well. I can't even imagine how they're gonna pull one of Syaoran's incantations with the current seiyuu.
Koko ni ite

Offline Tatasenko

  • Fai is more than definitely French !
  • "Die-Hard Fan!"
  • *****
  • Posts: 1,576
  • Gender: Female
  • Personal text here! Edit this on your profile page.
Re: TRC: Anime vs. Manga
« Reply #34 on: August 16 2006, 07:02 pm »
the only thing that is really worthy in the anime are the music,which are totally wonderful,a true opera  :okay:
moreover they always match perfectly with the actions,so it helps us bear the mediocre quality of the animation  :keke:


* "Mokona's kidnappers" guild * (http://www.capturedwings.net/forums/index.php?topic=3381.msg188911;topicseen#msg188911)
Team mate : Ishiyaki (journalist)
Subordinates : Sailor Yue Chan : Spy / Suu No Clover : Doctor / Airashii : Strategist / Kjesta : Factor

* Forum Family *
Ishiyaki : Team mate of the "Mokona's kidnappers" guild / Kina : Cookies shopkeeper / Nectar rain : The happy lucky cheerful girl / Airashii : banner's creator / SailorYue Chan : Twins / Moon Li : French counterpart / Kjesta : Soulmate / Znuese : Rainbow summoner and Brother

Offline Sailor Yue-chan

  • Vampire <3 FTW
  • *Freak Fan?!*
  • *****
  • Posts: 2,926
  • Gender: Female
  • So many yaoi OTPs.... so litlte time =3
Re: TRC: Anime vs. Manga
« Reply #35 on: August 16 2006, 07:38 pm »
did i vote in this poll? O_o

manga is definalty better. by far. the only part of the anome tath was done good was the movie. tho there was pretty minimal actuion in it, the animation was done far better. the character designs matched the manga designs better than beetrains. (the only beef i have of the movie character designs were the eyes. fai's eyes needed to be bigger and brigher and syaorans needed to be a shade lighter.) otherwise everything, right down to the length of fai's hair was done terrificly. beetrain on the other hand, i dred every second of tokyo, from kamui and kurogane's face off at the start
Show content
i seriosuly doubt we'll see kuro use his technique on kamui like inthe manga. no wall slamming for that fight
  to the current situation :( its better to leave that kind of thing to the imagination then to see betrain ruin it. (i SEIORNLY hope they atleast gett the GOOD animaters to do tokyo, not the F-Up animaters they had at the start of shura. kamui is cute, but i dont want my first impression of him in the anime to be wonky :(
-----
When you fall in love, gender does not matter. You can't help who your heart chooses, it just HAPPENS. So don't try to fight it, you'll only end up hurt.

-----
Please contribute to my TVRage Tsubasa Chronicle Guide
-----
Part of the Remember Hideki comittee/antiBeetrain comittee
-----
Online mangas @msn:
Tsubasa RESERVoir CHRoNiCLeS
xxxHOLIC
Forum Family:
Lil Sis:
Kairi
Cousin: kudan
Big Sis: Møon Li
Twin:Tatasenko

not mine

Offline Tatasenko

  • Fai is more than definitely French !
  • "Die-Hard Fan!"
  • *****
  • Posts: 1,576
  • Gender: Female
  • Personal text here! Edit this on your profile page.
Re: TRC: Anime vs. Manga
« Reply #36 on: August 17 2006, 07:08 am »
Beetrain MUST animated CLEARLY the recent chapter if we ever want to see some wonderful AMV based on Kurogane and Fai  :okay: (if they do a awful job,the "Mokona's kidnappers" guild will show them what a "angry fan" means  :angry:)


* "Mokona's kidnappers" guild * (http://www.capturedwings.net/forums/index.php?topic=3381.msg188911;topicseen#msg188911)
Team mate : Ishiyaki (journalist)
Subordinates : Sailor Yue Chan : Spy / Suu No Clover : Doctor / Airashii : Strategist / Kjesta : Factor

* Forum Family *
Ishiyaki : Team mate of the "Mokona's kidnappers" guild / Kina : Cookies shopkeeper / Nectar rain : The happy lucky cheerful girl / Airashii : banner's creator / SailorYue Chan : Twins / Moon Li : French counterpart / Kjesta : Soulmate / Znuese : Rainbow summoner and Brother

Offline Tricky

  • New Fan
  • *
  • Posts: 97
  • Gender: Female
Re: TRC: Anime vs. Manga
« Reply #37 on: September 19 2006, 02:39 pm »
The manga, obviously because its 100% CLAMP.
The anime belittles the characters and what they go through and ALL of the relationships. They try to come up with something new, a scene done differently, or in the Ashura/Yasha situation more scenes, but it looses the effect and meaning CLAMP originally planned for it.
The anime lacks feeling.
....The soundtrack is good thoguh....
You are special to me. Let me be your Kage-nie.


Proud Member of the Remember Hideki Campaign

Offline Renaya

  • Obsessed Fan
  • ***
  • Posts: 499
  • Gender: Female
  • everything about ayaness ~~
Re: TRC: Anime vs. Manga
« Reply #38 on: September 19 2006, 02:48 pm »
of course the manga yayy....And I guess others already made the point  :heh:

"Hear my silent prayer.....Heed my quiet call
When the Dark and Blue surround you...Step into my sight
Look inside the Light...You will know that I have found you"
from Dreamcatcher by Secret Garden

Offline Mairi

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 36
Re: TRC: Anime vs. Manga
« Reply #39 on: September 19 2006, 06:34 pm »
I'm another one voting for manga. Every single one of my favorite, most adored scenes in the manga were completely omitted from the anime. The characters look strange, move strangely, and lack everything that makes their manga selves endearing. When the anime came out a while ago I was really excited about it, and downloaded the first 3 episodes.

...I only made it through one and a half before getting bored, and I'm a very patient person.

Now, I understand why they've dumbed everything down, but I can't understand the complete lack of quality and characterization in the anime. Even with severe limitations for blood and drinking, I'm sure this could have been handled better. u_u

It's a little difficult for me to word how much more emotion is being expressed through the manga, but (I won't get into spoilers, so don't worry) when chapter 120 hit, I can't believe how much my heart sank at the last page. I was actually very much into a different series at the time and almost forgetting a little about TRC, sadly, but after that chapter I had trouble sleeping that night. I talked about it for the next two weeks. I have seen more episodes of the anime, and it has never had that impact, and never could with the style it has fallen into.

Ahhh, I've talked so much. u_u (Also what I have said has been mentioned in everyone's posts already, so probably this is pointless...)