CLAMP's Famous Works > Season 2
[TRC Arc 2] Episode 16: The Other Side of Nostalgia
Sailor Yue-chan:
@ part of your review:
--- Quote ---Show contentOh and... I thought Fye couldn't whistle?
--- End quote ---
Show contentthe animators ruined the build up. ll thruout their time in "clow" fai halfwhistles, like he did at the end of ep 41...only a timy sound. in tha manga, while they were looking for the book, and kuro pushed the book helf, the written sound effet was "pyuu' rther then "hyuu"... even at one point he went "ne kuromin, did that sound like a whistle?" (of course kuro was rather BUSY atthe moment XP) when fai throws his bowler inro the acid, thats the first time "pyuu" was drawn with music notes around it.
fai's whistle magic was suposed to be far more dramatic then it was in the anime.
http://tinyurl.com/mzbdb
http://tinyurl.com/fsf3e
http://tinyurl.com/kjcg8
http://tinyurl.com/zncca
http://i1.tinypic.com/261kz6p.jpg
http://tinyurl.com/zsru4
http://tinyurl.com/fg4tb
even if your NOT a manga reader...red that excerpt if you want to know the TRUE emotion of the scene <_<
Kjesta:
The only thing I liked about this episode was the music *sigh* The whistle was pretty disappointing, it didn't even sound cool. (Whatever I had expected was definitely NOT an Asian sounding flute or something.)
And it somehow bothers me that his magic is blue >>" I know, it's supposed to be blue, but the scene in the manga just screams "pale green" to me.
The whole thing how they come out of the library and such - it just lacks all the "ZOMG WTF HE USED MAGIC?!" *sniff*
Xiao_Lang:
--- Quote from: Super Sailor Yue on August 31 2006, 01:21 am ---@ part of your review:Show contentthe animators ruined the build up. ll thruout their time in "clow" fai halfwhistles, like he did at the end of ep 41...only a timy sound. in tha manga, while they were looking for the book, and kuro pushed the book helf, the written sound effet was "pyuu' rther then "hyuu"... even at one point he went "ne kuromin, did that sound like a whistle?" (of course kuro was rather BUSY atthe moment XP) when fai throws his bowler inro the acid, thats the first time "pyuu" was drawn with music notes around it.
fai's whistle magic was suposed to be far more dramatic then it was in the anime.
http://tinyurl.com/mzbdb
http://tinyurl.com/fsf3e
http://tinyurl.com/kjcg8
http://tinyurl.com/zncca
http://i1.tinypic.com/261kz6p.jpg
http://tinyurl.com/zsru4
http://tinyurl.com/fg4tb
even if your NOT a manga reader...red that excerpt if you want to know the TRUE emotion of the scene <_<
--- End quote ---
ahh thanks.. ^_^ I obviously didn't pay close enough attention whilst reading that manga chapter! >__<
but your right, Bee train have a record at draining any emotion from a scene
Sailor Yue-chan:
indeed. the manga your ike "O.O OMG did he just DO that?" whilst in the anime your like, "huh? what? oh...fai used his magic. ok *shrugs*"
nd your right, to me the use of his magic in the maga soundedin my head like a haounting ghstly whstiling, and the sheild slowly rising., not like a flute sound and POOF insta-sheild.
--- Quote from: Kjesta on August 31 2006, 01:28 am ---The only thing I liked about this episode was the music *sigh* The whistle was pretty disappointing, it didn't even sound cool. (Whatever I had expected was definitely NOT an Asian sounding flute or something.)
And it somehow bothers me that his magic is blue >>" I know, it's supposed to be blue, but the scene in the manga just screams "pale green" to me.
The whole thing how they come out of the library and such - it just lacks all the "ZOMG WTF HE USED MAGIC?!" *sniff*
--- End quote ---
Kuro-puppy:
--- Quote from: Super Sailor Yue on August 31 2006, 02:34 am ---indeed. the manga your ike "O.O OMG did he just DO that?" whilst in the anime your like, "huh? what? oh...fai used his magic. ok *shrugs*"
--- End quote ---
you have read the manga where the scene was "O.O OMG" but then when you watch the anime you already know he is gonna do that, doesn't that make it less "O.O OMG" as well?
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version