That's another thing about CLAMP that you start to notice after reading some of their others works: they are very firm about that even if a character isn't a "real" person (for example, if they are a machine or created through magic), that still doesn't make them any less real.
Oh I didn't mean that he didn't deserve her because he wasn't "real" or anything like that. As long as he grows his own heart I guess I'm alright with the whole Clone and Sakura thing (even though I don't really like them as a pairing as of yet), however, I think it would be unfair for him to get back R!Syaoran's heart when it never belonged to him in the first place... And it would make me one very unhappy fangirl.
That was, among other, a running theme in Chobits, and many of the characters that appear in TRC shouldn't logically be able to exist in other dimensions since they, in their original manga, were created by someone else and thought of as having no soul/feelings.
In the case of Chii though, wasn't she created by Fai in Celes? So that makes sense - even in a different dimension she was still a created thing.
We saw all through the series that Sakura’s body is naturally inclined towards Syaoran-kun’s without her heart.
Sakura never actually lost her heart, she just lost her memories.
Why else would she reach out for him when she was asleep in Piffle?
Uhh I can't remember.. When was that?
I think the body could start to develop a heart because back in Volume 9 Mokona said how everyone has both body memories and heart memories (not to be confused with Sakura‘s ability to store world memories..). So why wouldn’t clonie have them too?
He could start to develop a heart but there is no evidence of this as of yet.
Right now his body is just like Sakura’s was at the beginning of the series, ne?
Sort of. But not really. Like I say, at the beginning of the series Sakura lost her memories, whereas Cloney lost his heart. But then again he didn't really lose it since it was never really his.
he made a whole eye!sex scene out of it…….
Really?? I thought that whole scene was just supposed to prove that even having a pleading Sakura at his feet didn't make a difference to him. Proof that he is now a heart-less being with no other objective than to collect feathers.
Ummm….LoL. I think you just stated both sides of that argument xDD
<3.
Lol yeah :/
You do wonder though how FWR can sit in front of that TV-set thing watching the group 24/7. Doesn't he ever sleep? Why doesn't he have square-eyes by now? xD Actually, come to think of it, didn't his mother ever teach him not to meddle in other people's lives for his own selfish gain?As for Sakura bed angst scene…I saw it differently. It was more like Sakura was trying to get into her head the idea that R!Syaoran was her most precious but although they looked the same and had the same steady gaze or whatever it was like something inside of her was going against that idea. And I think she’s feeling more guilty because she wants R!Syaoran TO be her Syaoran but he just can’t be.
Uhh well this is what I think about it...
Sakura says: "I know that even if he's the original he's like the ones we met in the other worlds - the same face but different persons.
Still.. it's no good.." = I think by this she means basically that: It's no good, I still have feelings for the real Syaoran no matter how much I try not to.
Because why else would she say "Still.. it's no good" in that context?
Also she says: "Each time I come across him. It's hopeless.
Why? The one right in front of me isn't Syaoran-kun is he?" = She is asking herself "why" she is falling for R!Syaoran and she is frightened of this because she believes she fell in love with Cloney.
But, yeah, I guess we'll just have to agree to disagree on this ^^
This will sound insane but….*blushes*….if Syaoran was meant to only be one person, then why would they even play with the idea of putting a twin in the drama CD….?
Because CLAMP are evil and take pleasure out of teasing their fans
As for dress maybe all souls should look like that….while Syaoran-kun couldn’t be all nice and flowy and white because he had to create a heart of his own. And I think it would be suiting because that was how he created himself to be…all covered in filth because his soul’s all dirty from killing and being psychotic. I always found it highly symbolic that Sakura was clean and white while Syaoran was “of earth” (his outfit actually being from his life on earth) with torn up clothes and dirty flesh….both literally and psychically.
Very interesting theory but I don't know if it's likely to be as symbolic as that. I mean, at first I theorized that the whole tube was supposed to be symbolic.. but I was wrong.
If we're going into possible vs non-possible then we should start discussing how you program a lifeless body to only collect feathers O.o;
True, why I am trying to make logical sense out of something that has been labelled as being of the fantasy genre?
