CLAMP's Famous Works > Manga Chapter Discussions

187

<< < (4/4)

gara_to:

--- Quote from: Ando on April 13 2008, 11:27 pm ---Show contentYes, probably, and that would also mean that initially, the person C!Syaoran considered most precious was R!Sakura. Although, since this is CLAMP we're dealing with, there's no saying they won't pull something unexpected once again that puts everything in a whole new light. We did however see (in chapter 179, I think) that it was indeed in the ruins that Sakura was cloned. But, again, CLAMP might just be playing with our heads and making us believe that.

I think it's important to remember, though, that CLAMP usually make a difference between "being in love" and "considering someone your most important person" - the latter is more heartfelt; the Ultimate Kind of Love that Spans Universes, and while C!Syaoran considered R!Sakura his most important person, she "only" loved him.

Moreover, if we assume that the real Syaoran and Sakura considered each other their most precious person but Sakura's memories were altered once Syaoran was kidnapped, her love for him should still be present in her heart (since True Love seems to be a part of a person's very soul in CLAMPverse), and be stronger than the love she felt for the clone. Uh, now I feel like I'm rambling, so I shall stop here and hope that I'm making myself understood...
--- End quote ---

Wow! You sure know a lot about clamp. I'm a new comer in the anime fandom so I'm learning a lot from you. :okay:

Show contentYeah! It wasn't directly stated that she was cloned there so they really might be playing with our heads. There is also this theory circling around in other forums. According to them, RSyaoran might have come from the other world and they go as far as thinking that RSyaoran might be the CCS Syaoran. I think it's possible knowing that the sword RSyaoran used when he is fighting is the same with CCS Syaoran. But would Clamp do that,? I know that they have a thing  for crossovers but  do they do continuation of their finished manga?

Ando:
Thank you for that flattering comment, and welcome to the forum, gara_to!


--- Quote from: gara_to on April 15 2008, 12:26 am ---There is also this theory circling around in other forums. According to them, RSyaoran might have come from the other world and they go as far as thinking that RSyaoran might be the CCS Syaoran. I think it's possible knowing that the sword RSyaoran used when he is fighting is the same with CCS Syaoran. But would Clamp do that,? I know that they have a thing  for crossovers but  do they do continuation of their finished manga?
--- End quote ---

Yes, CLAMP do continuations of many of their older works. For example, characters from two of their older series, Tokyo Babylon and Clamp School Detectives, reoccur in the manga X which takes place in the same world several years after the other two were finished. These crossover characters, however, only play a minor part in X whereas in their original series, they were main characters.

That theory has been discussed a lot on this forum too, and frankly, I think it's completely illogical. If you compare the TRC timeline with that of CCS you'll see that it doesn't add up. As for Syaoran's sword and techniques being the same, I don't think that proves anything. Take the crossover character Yasha (who appears in TRC in Shurano country) for example, who has the exact same technique as his original self and is still very clearly an alternate self. I think it's important to remember that almost all TRC characters are crossovers, and that they therefore obviously will have things in common with their original self.

Tatasenko:

--- Quote from: gara_to on April 15 2008, 12:26 am ---Wow! You sure know a lot about clamp. I'm a new comer in the anime fandom so I'm learning a lot from you. :okay:

Show contentYeah! It wasn't directly stated that she was cloned there so they really might be playing with our heads. There is also this theory circling around in other forums. According to them, RSyaoran might have come from the other world and they go as far as thinking that RSyaoran might be the CCS Syaoran. I think it's possible knowing that the sword RSyaoran used when he is fighting is the same with CCS Syaoran. But would Clamp do that,? I know that they have a thing  for crossovers but  do they do continuation of their finished manga?
--- End quote ---

hey Ando,you seem to have become the new master of  the forum around here ^^
by the way welcome Gara_to,this forum is really one of the most interesting about CLAMP universe!
even if it is not as busy as some months ago it is still always pleasant to spend time here especially thanks to the richness of the various topics and because the menbers are very adorable,it has been two years since i came on this forum and i have NEVER had an argument with anyone ^^

concerning your theory of real Syaoran being in fact CCS syaoran,it has been proven wrong because of the chronology of the events.Real Syaoran has been held captive many years in a tube since he was seven years old until he was fourteen,so the story of Tsubasa reservoir Chronicles couldn't have taken place before or after the story of Card Captor Sakura since in this one he met Sakura when he was roughly ten years old.
so now we have to deal with three Syaoran,the real,the clone,and the CCS ^^

Ando:

--- Quote from: Tatasenko on April 15 2008, 06:31 am ---hey Ando,you seem to have become the new master of  the forum around here ^^
--- End quote ---

Lol, and to think that when I first registered here, I had only read CCS. ^^'


--- Quote from: Tatasenko on April 15 2008, 06:31 am ---concerning your theory of real Syaoran being in fact CCS syaoran,it has been proven wrong because of the chronology of the events.
--- End quote ---
The odd thing is that since the recent revelations about Sakura, a lot of people are now certain that R!Sakura is also CCS!Sakura...

Tatasenko:

--- Quote from: Ando on April 15 2008, 06:46 am ---Lol, and to think that when I first registered here, I had only read CCS. ^^'
The odd thing is that since the recent revelations about Sakura, a lot of people are now certain that R!Sakura is also CCS!Sakura...

--- End quote ---

really,i can't understand why people keep believing that real sakura and CCS are the same person,it is obvious that the two manga stories can't entertwined themselves,it would be totally illogical!
according to the revelation of this chapter,if real Syaoran was CCS Syaoran and real Sakura was CCS Sakura it would meant that they have met each other before they were seven years old,which would not fit at all the storyline of Card Captor Sakura since there they have met when they were more than ten years old...

hum,the ONLY CASE that would prove true their theory is that real Sakura would have been replaced by clone Sakura when she was roughly ten years old,and that she would have been sent in the universe of Card Captor Sakura with her memories of her childhood in TRC universe erased.
then she would have met CCS Syaoran at her school and would have lived her adventures as a card captor,and when the story of  Card captor sakura would have came to an end (when she was nearly  foorteen),she would have been taken back in the world of TRC with again her memories of her life in the world of Card Captor Sakura nullified,and her memories of her chidhood in TRC brough back,and so she would have been directly transfered in Fei Wong Reed's lair since this is where her real body has been kept when clone Sakura took her place...

oh my gosh,this is the crappiest theory i have ever made,i have written this mess without believing it for one second,i must be barmy ^^

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[*] Previous page