CLAMP's Famous Works > Cardcaptor Sakura

The heresy that is Cardcaptors.

<< < (70/101) > >>

Takeru:
So if Cardcaptors was its own show, and there was no such thing as Card Captor Sakura, and Cardcaptors was actually an original creation by Nelvana, and if no one ever knew that Card Captor Sakura even existed, would Cardcaptors be a good show to you?

By the way, SLi, Cardcaptors isn't THAT horrible. At least Nelvana did some things right. Some. Look at the positives, why don't you...

Ruby Chan:
Since Cardcaptors is what got me into Cardcaptor Sakura, then yeah, Cardcaptors would be a good show. And even though people say that S+S got erased, if you watched closely, you could pick up on hints that showed how Li's feelings were changing towards Sakura.

Personally, I think Cardcaptors was a great series (although I wathced the version with all 70 episodes), and the only reason people think it's rubbish is because they're comparing an original show to the dub - most dubs are worse than the originals, so don't pick on Nelvana! They tried their best!

DarkWolfYoukai:
nelvana, trying their best?  :rotfl:  they just wanted something to go up against pokemon for ratings.  though, if cardcaptors was the original and there was no ccs, it would be like yu-gi-oh to me.  like it for a while, then watch it just because it's there.  yes, i watch yu-gi-oh just because it's there.

Sakaki:
***So if Cardcaptors was its own show, and there was no such thing as Card Captor Sakura, and Cardcaptors was actually an original creation by Nelvana, and if no one ever knew that Card Captor Sakura even existed, would Cardcaptors be a good show to you?***

I have to say it would still **** big time.
First, I have to admit I've only seen a few Cardcraptors episodes.
I've read the transcipts of them though and I know what they took out and what order they showed the episodes in here in America.
Cardcaptors makes no sense.
You have people smiling while they are yelling, you have Touya and Sakura acting totally out of character (bratty). They "Americanized" everything.
You have Syaoran blushing while they are talking about something totally unrelated to feelings.

The voice acting is really bad. Even if you NEVER even knew about CCS, you have to admit the voice acting on CC is really awful.
Everything was shown out of sequence making the plot meaningless.
All the relationships were torn out.
What was the point of CC?
What were they trying to convey with this show?

I'm commenting on the American version obviously.
That is the only version I really know much about.

Hmmm... that almost sounded like a rant.
Okay, one good thing about the dub......the animation.
One more...I admit it does introduce people to anime and makes them interested in finding out more about it.     Haha, just had to be fair here!

Miss Jenni-Maie:
Couldn't agree with you more Sakaki.
I've noticed so many errors when it came to that show...and I'm not talking about the relationships and such.

There's actually this one part in CC that has always peeved me off to the extreme. I can't remember what episode number it was but it was when Dash took off "in" Toya's bike. Near the begining of the episode, Kero is talking about how there won't be any "natural disasters" because one of the elemental cards were changed; Windy.
Mmm...wasn't the first card she changed Firey? And in the SAME episode later, she CHANGES Windy! Argh, it confused me, and peeved me off, greatly.
I still say Nelvana sucks at life.

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

[*] Previous page