CLAMP's Famous Works > Cardcaptor Sakura
The heresy that is Cardcaptors.
Ruby Chan:
Ok then. Apologise in advance if I slip back into country dubs anytime soon.
In my opinion, the dub wasn't that bad (full number of episodes version). The plot was covered, there was humour, adventure, friendship....if you watched it for the first time it was a great anime cartoon. I thikn it was only badif you'd seen the japanese version first, as you were able to pick up on cut scenes and script.
Otherwise, it was a good attempt, and Cardcaptors will always have a special place in my heart, as the first anime cartoon (other than Digimon) to really get me into anime.
fisah:
*nods* Pretty sure I mentioned this earlier, because CC got us into anime! When I look at it that way, it doesn't seem so bad.
But, when its compared to the original, then, well, it isnt so good is it? I think CC was an adaption rather than a dub, if anyone remembers Sailor Moon, it was the same idea, except, most of the romance was kept in, and CC aired a couple years later than SM.
Cardcaptor Takato:
--- Quote from: Ruby Chan on May 31 2005, 11:17 pm ---Ok then. Apologise in advance if I slip back into country dubs anytime soon.
In my opinion, the dub wasn't that bad (full number of episodes version). The plot was covered, there was humour, adventure, friendship....if you watched it for the first time it was a great anime cartoon. I thikn it was only badif you'd seen the japanese version first, as you were able to pick up on cut scenes and script.
Otherwise, it was a good attempt, and Cardcaptors will always have a special place in my heart, as the first anime cartoon (other than Digimon) to really get me into anime.
--- End quote ---
Yeah, by itself CC wasn't all that bad. You have to admit that the action scenes were exiciting and the animation in CC was a lot better than the animation in most of the other anime that was aired on Saturday mornings around that era. I lost count of how many times I watched the CC movie when I was a dubbie. Still, even though I saw CC before the original and it did help me to get hooked on CLAMP, I can't stand to watch it anymore after seeing CCS because I know that something superior is missing from the show, not to mention the English VAs and stupid dialog always annoyed me to no end.
fisah:
Yes, agree! CC is good when it isn't compared to CCS! I guess we are neutral when it comes to this, ne?
But the quality of the animation was good, at least, better than Pokemon *cringes*
Robin Sena:
I wonder if time constraints is the issue of less episodes.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version