CLAMP's Famous Works > Cardcaptor Sakura
The heresy that is Cardcaptors.
Cardcaptor Takato:
Looking back at CC, had Nelvana only cut out the relationships that are considered to be "unacceptable" for children's American television, do you think Sakura x Shaoran still would've made sense? I mean, think about it. A big important part about Sakura x Shaoran are Sakura and Shaoran's unrequited feelings for Yukito. Even if Nelvana left in Sakura's innocent crush on Yukito, how would they have been able to explain why Yukito rejected her? How would they have been able to explain when Shaoran is struggling with the differences between his feelings for Yukito and the other feeling he has for Sakura? While targeting the show more at boys does play a huge factor in cutting out all the relationships in CCS, I also personally believe that the "innocent" relationships wouldn't have made any sense had they been left in because the more controversial relationships are so important to them.
DarkWolfYoukai:
--- Quote from: Cardcaptor Takato on July 15 2005, 10:54 pm ---Looking back at CC, had Nelvana only cut out the relationships that are considered to be "unacceptable" for children's American television, do you think Sakura x Shaoran still would've made sense? I mean, think about it. A big important part about Sakura x Shaoran are Sakura and Shaoran's unrequited feelings for Yukito. Even if Nelvana left in Sakura's innocent crush on Yukito, how would they have been able to explain why Yukito rejected her? How would they have been able to explain when Shaoran is struggling with the differences between his feelings for Yukito and the other feeling he has for Sakura? While targeting the show more at boys does play a huge factor in cutting out all the relationships in CCS, I also personally believe that the "innocent" relationships wouldn't have made any sense had they been left in because the more controversial relationships are so important to them.
--- End quote ---
you have a point there, but the yukito rejecting sakura thing would be easy to explain. there was quite an age difference between the two, so that's a possible reason. though, how to explain syaoran's struggle with his feelings without him liking yukito has no reasonable explanation i can think of. now that you point that out, it does seem a little better they left the relationship out, though they could have hid syaoran's blushing better or taken it out altogether. still not a fan of the dub though.
Hikari B.:
Ah, ya gotta hate Nelvana. I hated them for cutting out the SS relationship. T_T
Arcademan:
hikari blaze...why did you bump this topic back up?!!
We have a current one going at the moment...totally unnecessary.
You may want to read up on the new rules:
--- Quote ---4. Do Not Unnecessarily "Bump" Old Topics
You are allowed to post on any topic found in the first 3 pages of each forum. Those are still considered to be 'Active' topics. All other topics from page 4 and beyond are considered 'Archived'. You may post in them to "bump" them back to the first page but ONLY if you have a good purpose or you have something useful to contribute to the discussion.
Do not only write "bump" in your post. You must also explain why you're bumping the topic.
--- End quote ---
Request a lock and load on this one!!!
D.J.P:
Rules are rules.
- Topic locked
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[*] Previous page
Go to full version