AuthorTopic: The heresy that is Cardcaptors.  (Read 106764 times)

0 Members and 8 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline Sakaki

  • "Die-Hard Fan!"
  • *****
  • Posts: 1,563
  • Gender: Female
Re: The heresy that is Cardcaptors.
« Reply #300 on: April 30 2005, 04:16 pm »
You can get info on some of the American changes and can compare a handful of episodes here:
http://ccsvscc.com/

I remember reading when I first really got into Cardcaptor Sakura, and couldn't believe how they destroyed what they brought to America!

Offline Takeru

  • Former Staff
  • Obsessed Fan
  • *
  • Posts: 455
  • Gender: Male
Re: The heresy that is Cardcaptors.
« Reply #301 on: May 01 2005, 03:02 pm »
Hmm, some people have been complaining about Eriol's dub name.

Well, if they kept in Eriol's name, then the Americans would pronounce it "Ariel", which is a girl's name. Why they didn't keep the Japanese pronounciation instead? Erioru sounds kinda dumb in American tongue too, and an American would probably pronounce it "Ediodu", which sounds ridiculous.  So I'm actually kinda "I don't mind Eriol's name change".
The world won't give me a chance. I'm done asking for one.

Offline Miss Jenni-Maie

  • Dean Winchester is tied up in my closet!
  • "Die-Hard Fan!"
  • *****
  • Posts: 2,240
  • Gender: Female
  • 100% Dean Winchester Obsessed!
Re: The heresy that is Cardcaptors.
« Reply #302 on: May 01 2005, 03:10 pm »
Yeah, I'm fine with the name change with Eriol, too.
I'm okay with name changes, but when it gets DRAMATICALLY changed like Tomoyo to Madison, that just gets me angry.

But yeah, Eriol to Eli....not that much of a difference, so I'm fine with it.
Or Yukito to Julian [shiver] it's just not right.

The same with Toya to Tori. It's not that big of a difference, even though I think people would be able to pronounce that, I'm kinda okay with it. Nadeshiko to Natasha, Sonomi to Samantha. Naoko to Nikki, Chiharu to Chelsea, Rika to Rita. As much as I don't like English dubbed names in Japanese Anime, those weren't too drastic, so they don't bother me too much.
~--------~~--------~
Rest in peace my furry friend.
Cinnamon - November 15th, 1990 - January 21st, 2006
~--------------------~
-AV NOT made by me. Creater unknown.-

Offline Robin Sena

  • Now with 100% more fads!
  • "Die-Hard Fan!"
  • *****
  • Posts: 1,679
  • BOING!
Re: The heresy that is Cardcaptors.
« Reply #303 on: May 01 2005, 03:23 pm »
I wish it was released at the right time. I wouldn't mind on the other changes.

Well, YOU JUST HAVE TO TALK!
click!
Fanfic - CLAMP in Gradius World (Fanfic Done! 26 Chapters)<br />Next Fanfic - Monster Hunter Diaries *NEW!*
Story of Infinite Possibilities - Blocks Made. Block 1 - Fate (Fate, Testament, Eternity) Block 2 - Infinity (Infinity, Memento, Betrayal) Block 3 - World Order (World Order, Metempsychosis, Damnation) Special Edition - 155 cards made<br />Next Block! - Kaleido Dreams! (Kaleido Dreams, Angelic Voices, Snow Sunlight)<br />
Nirvana TEST BLOCK!

Offline Sakaki

  • "Die-Hard Fan!"
  • *****
  • Posts: 1,563
  • Gender: Female
Re: The heresy that is Cardcaptors.
« Reply #304 on: May 01 2005, 05:33 pm »
***Well, if they kept in Eriol's name, then the Americans would pronounce it "Ariel", which is a girl's name.***

Actually before I ever heard the name pronounced I just thought Errol.
kinda like air-rel, if that makes sense.

After watching CCS I found Eriol's name easy to pronounce.
I still don't really care for Eli though, but I don't watch the dubs, so it's never bothered me that much! I don't like Tori for Touya though.
I think Tori, and I think of a girl. Touya carries a lot more weight and power than Tori.

Offline DarkWolfYoukai

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 33
  • Gender: Female
  • Personal text here! Edit this on your profile page
Re: The heresy that is Cardcaptors.
« Reply #305 on: May 02 2005, 08:29 pm »
***Well, if they kept in Eriol's name, then the Americans would pronounce it "Ariel", which is a girl's name.***

Actually before I ever heard the name pronounced I just thought Errol.
kinda like air-rel, if that makes sense.

that does make sense because i used to do that too.  heck, kero's english pronounced name still influences how i pronounce kero!  since, this was my first anime i saw in japanese, my ability to pronounce japanese names came too late for the poor CCS characters, and it's all because of nelbaka and that evil cardcraptors.

Offline Obsessive Touga Fan

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 3
  • Personal text here! Edit this on your profile page.
Re: The heresy that is Cardcaptors.
« Reply #306 on: May 03 2005, 03:00 am »
Only one mix occurred - that one at the end (involving episodes 69/70)
Once again, there was only one mixed episodes, trust me, I've seen all (and have available to me) all 70 episodes of Cardcaptors.

There were four other combined episodes. This can be partly confirmed from the fact that three of them are available on R1 DVD. Volume 7 contains the US version of "One Fateful Day", which uses episode 41 as a framing device for flashbacks to episode 1. Read the reviews at Amazon, and Anime on DVD's review, to clarify this. Yes, it's different to the episode also called "One Fateful Day" that was aired everywhere except the US.

Similarly, volume 9 contains "A Strange New Beginning" (episodes 46 and 47) and "A New Set of Wings" (50 and 51). Once again, look at the Amazon reviews and AoD's review to see plot summaries that confirm the episodes were combined. For example, "A New Set of Wings" has Sakura buying the teddy bear kit and getting the new wings within the same episode. (Plus it'd be kind of odd if the first episode on this DVD was just episode 46 or 47... it'd basically be half of a two-part episode.)

However: Non-combined versions of them ALSO exist. I saw them when they aired on UK TV. I remember reading a lot of discussing at the CCU forum when the combined episodes were aired in the US, and being very surprised to see that they were separate (and of course MUCH less heavily edited) in the UK. It's weird, but no weirder than the fact that they dubbed 31 episodes that didn't air in the US at all. (I guess if you account for the different versions, and "The Past, the Present and the Future", there are technically 75 Cardcaptors episodes.)

I'm very jealous of the fact that you have all 70 UK/Australia aired episodes on tape o_o I love Cardcaptor Sakura dearly, but I enjoy CC a lot too - partly despite the changes, and partly because of them. I find it very interesting to compare the two versions.
« Last Edit: May 03 2005, 10:20 pm by Obsessive Touga Fan »

Offline Hira

  • Good Fan
  • **
  • Posts: 137
  • Personal text here! Edit this on your profile page.
Re: The heresy that is Cardcaptors.
« Reply #307 on: May 05 2005, 02:49 pm »
The society five years ago is very, very different comparing to today.
I don't think average audience has been exposed to sensitive topics, particularly homosexuality (CLAMP put a little bit of those in their works) back then, and certainly not romance between kids (probably fear of parents suing the company for showing kids stuff about datings, love letter, etc...)
Before I watched CCS, I watched CC, too... I always thought Tomoyo is just Sakura's lackey/ friend, but when watching the Japanese series... Wow... I never realized... you are lesbian, just like your mother who has this undying affection for Nadeshiko... (CLAMP even drew picture of Tomoyo holding Sakura's chin to kiss her)
Many of you have also talked about Meilin comes crying to Tomoyo being edited out, another romance involved scene ( but that is the time I begin to like Meilin...)
Another thing is, I think it is likely that Western cultures are focusing more on things like gaining of powers and strengths and victories in battle (Screw You, World War I & II !!! You two ruined humanity!!!)
My point in saying that?  When you guys watched CC, did you also feel that the series seem to just revolve around catching cards and being the spectators of competitions between the two sorcerors?  Also... they edited the episode w/ the teddy bear exhibit where instead of Sakura telling Li that him calling her by her first name for the first time gave her the boost to call out a card to save herself, it was his mom calling him to stay in Japan as a prove that Syaoran is still "worthy".

Conclusion: as much as Nelvana is conscious about the possible offensive issues that might disturb those who are under much influence of Western cultures, the company should still show these issues the way CLAMP intended...
A. Kids know about love and romance.  For goodness sake, they've watched Snow White, Sleeping Beauty, and Aladdin, haven't they?  Disney even put in kissing scenes while CLAMP never put one in for any of their couples (Except Sorata and Arashi)... Irony, huh...
B. CLAMP, through romance, wants to show its audience the good that comes out of a world where people are committed and truly concerned about each other, and, most importantly, what it meant to love a person, that even if it is painful, even if it may never have a result, you would still be wililng to do anything for that person because it would be MORE painful to see them suffer as they become a part of you... Syaoran loves Sakura, but he is willing to just quietly stand by her side because he does not want her to cry again after that rejection from Yukito.  Tomoyo loves Sakura, but she knows Sakura loves Li instead, but she is still willing to be by Sakura's side whenever possible.  Meilin loves Syaoran, but after knowing that Syaoran loves Sakura, she never hated Sakura for it.  She just hates herself for unable to be mad at anyone but herself and gives herself a good cry, and then do anything she can to make Syaoran gets the happy ending he wants by giving him every opportunity to tell Sakura about his feelings...
In truth, while I watched CC for the sake of entertainment, I actually learned a lot from the character's selfless love when watching CCS, which helped me learn to become a better person.
Good god, I write so much, who'd read it? Honestly, though, maybe if people in America watched CLAMP works, there might not be so many pointless blind dates, speedy marriages, and secret affairs going on.

Offline fisah

  • "Die-Hard Fan!"
  • *****
  • Posts: 1,690
  • Gender: Female
  • Pathetically Obesessed
Re: The heresy that is Cardcaptors.
« Reply #308 on: May 05 2005, 11:32 pm »
I totally agree with you, CLAMP is wonderful when it comes to love and angst.

Also, I think I mentioned this a couple of times, but, the Americans, are biased in terms of anime works.  If it's made in there country, with sex scenes, I betch you they'd play it. However, I really didn't see the problem with CCS in terms of homosexualtiy and stuff. I mean, what kid who'd look into those things, it's all about the entertainment, and enjoying it, something I didn't have when I watched CC.

I think Nelvana took their 'good intentions' a little to far. They edited out all the emotions, and feelings, that are vital to the plot. You see, when they do that, I notice something is missing, in way you could say the show wasn't complete.

Okay, I'm rambling, but yeah, I hope I explained it good, and  the stuff you wrote was intresting, and  I bet alot of people will read it ^_-
A Dream
A Glitter
A Peacful Serenity



Kira x Lacus

Forum Family <3

Little Sister- Zeldi
Sister-Lika-chi (twin? XD), Endoh, Angelic-Essence
Big Sister- moezy-chan, SofiaofCardcaptors, bluetopaz
Big Brother-Tooya_Mizuki

Offline Ruby Chan

  • Yet Another Anime Obsessive
  • "Die-Hard Fan!"
  • *****
  • Posts: 2,102
  • Gender: Female
  • KuroFai Love
Re: The heresy that is Cardcaptors.
« Reply #309 on: May 06 2005, 06:03 am »
I used to think thta the english version wasn't edited...but whilst it had all the episodes, as opposed tot he american, it still had some major cuts....

I was watching a clip of Sakura telling Yukito that she loved him, when suddenly I tohugh; hey! This wasn't in the english version! I suppose they took it out because of the references to Yukito loving Toya...sigh


My Fanfiction              AnimeFicathon             My LJ
FORUM FAMILY -  Hori ~ Little Sister    Sakaki ~ Big Sister    Fai ~ Little Sister    VexNet ~ Big Brother
OniiChanTouya - Little Sister    Zeldi ~ Cousin     Pikari ~ Big Sister   lika-chi ~ Cousin     AkaiYuki ~ Aunt        Dragonia ~ Cousin       soficacardcaptors ~ Big Sister      bLuetopaz ~ Big Sister       S.Espoire ~ Cousin      
Charme* ~ Little Sister        Starfire ~ Big Sister      Asuka-chan ~ Little Sister

Offline Hira

  • Good Fan
  • **
  • Posts: 137
  • Personal text here! Edit this on your profile page.
Re: The heresy that is Cardcaptors.
« Reply #310 on: May 06 2005, 06:55 am »
I totally agree with you, CLAMP is wonderful when it comes to love and angst.

Also, I think I mentioned this a couple of times, but, the Americans, are biased in terms of anime works. If it's made in there country, with sex scenes, I betch you they'd play it. However, I really didn't see the problem with CCS in terms of homosexualtiy and stuff. I mean, what kid who'd look into those things, it's all about the entertainment, and enjoying it, something I didn't have when I watched CC.

I think Nelvana took their 'good intentions' a little to far. They edited out all the emotions, and feelings, that are vital to the plot. You see, when they do that, I notice something is missing, in way you could say the show wasn't complete.

Okay, I'm rambling, but yeah, I hope I explained it good, and the stuff you wrote was intresting, and I bet alot of people will read it ^_-
By eliminating the emotional scenes... Nelvana actually destroyed the major theme of CLAMP... Remember the catastrophe for letting loose Clow Cards is for people to forget the feelings they have for others?  Taking out that theme, it's a scary thought...
Nelvana created a series- long extension of Sakura's worst nightmare- a loveless world...
« Last Edit: May 06 2005, 11:03 am by Hira »

Offline fisah

  • "Die-Hard Fan!"
  • *****
  • Posts: 1,690
  • Gender: Female
  • Pathetically Obesessed
Re: The heresy that is Cardcaptors.
« Reply #311 on: May 06 2005, 10:40 am »
The very thing CLAMP wanted to get across *shakes head*

The whole show was about feelings, why can't Nelvana see that?!! They shouldn't have touched this show. I noticed some dubs weren't as bad as CC though, it's surprising how they could actually air that stuff o.0
A Dream
A Glitter
A Peacful Serenity



Kira x Lacus

Forum Family <3

Little Sister- Zeldi
Sister-Lika-chi (twin? XD), Endoh, Angelic-Essence
Big Sister- moezy-chan, SofiaofCardcaptors, bluetopaz
Big Brother-Tooya_Mizuki

Offline Miss Jenni-Maie

  • Dean Winchester is tied up in my closet!
  • "Die-Hard Fan!"
  • *****
  • Posts: 2,240
  • Gender: Female
  • 100% Dean Winchester Obsessed!
Re: The heresy that is Cardcaptors.
« Reply #312 on: May 07 2005, 08:33 am »
Apparently, emotions of any kind will rape and destroy the minds of the youngins.
Oh. And trigger the apocolypse.
~--------~~--------~
Rest in peace my furry friend.
Cinnamon - November 15th, 1990 - January 21st, 2006
~--------------------~
-AV NOT made by me. Creater unknown.-

Offline Takeru

  • Former Staff
  • Obsessed Fan
  • *
  • Posts: 455
  • Gender: Male
Re: The heresy that is Cardcaptors.
« Reply #313 on: May 07 2005, 09:45 am »
If they knew this show was so "inappropriate", why wouldn't they have left it to someone who would have put it on Toonami instead? I mean Toonami has revealing, bloody, emotional shows. CCS is too happy-go-lucky to be on Adult Swim, so I wouldn't recommend that.
« Last Edit: May 07 2005, 09:55 am by Takeru Â¥amamoto »
The world won't give me a chance. I'm done asking for one.

Offline Hira

  • Good Fan
  • **
  • Posts: 137
  • Personal text here! Edit this on your profile page.
Re: The heresy that is Cardcaptors.
« Reply #314 on: May 08 2005, 05:51 am »
Yeah, well... 2005 is when Americans begin to let certain things go when airing anime for kids... Remember that there weren't much anime on air 5-6 years ago... There was only Pokemon, which probably gave them the concept that all animes are the same and tried to make Cardcaptor a show about competitions and battles rather than the emotional themes...

But, watching anime right now, I think America is more open... *sigh*... Card Captor Sakura was just translated and aired at the wrong time...

Offline Robin Sena

  • Now with 100% more fads!
  • "Die-Hard Fan!"
  • *****
  • Posts: 1,679
  • BOING!
Re: The heresy that is Cardcaptors.
« Reply #315 on: May 08 2005, 03:15 pm »
Hira - now that you mentioned it. You're right, it's somewhat an extention of Sakura's alternate world where love doesn't exist.

Well, YOU JUST HAVE TO TALK!
click!
Fanfic - CLAMP in Gradius World (Fanfic Done! 26 Chapters)<br />Next Fanfic - Monster Hunter Diaries *NEW!*
Story of Infinite Possibilities - Blocks Made. Block 1 - Fate (Fate, Testament, Eternity) Block 2 - Infinity (Infinity, Memento, Betrayal) Block 3 - World Order (World Order, Metempsychosis, Damnation) Special Edition - 155 cards made<br />Next Block! - Kaleido Dreams! (Kaleido Dreams, Angelic Voices, Snow Sunlight)<br />
Nirvana TEST BLOCK!

Offline Ralea

  • Passing Through Life Unnoticed
  • "Die-Hard Fan!"
  • *****
  • Posts: 1,684
  • Gender: Female
  • When will we see each other again?
Re: The heresy that is Cardcaptors.
« Reply #316 on: May 08 2005, 04:46 pm »
I never wanna hear Sakura talking about 360's or Tomoyo talking about redesigning her website ever again.


~Forum family~                                             
Onii-chan : Kuropuppy
Onee-chan : Sayora Chan, lika-ichi
Ate : princess kakurine
Imoto-chan : Zeldi, Monse-chan
Twin sisters : fisah, xOLight AngelxO
Cousins : sofiacardcaptors, bluetopaz
Niece : Asuka

99% of the female population all think that Syaoran is the hottest bishie ever in both TRC & CCS. 1% is me! XD If you're one of the 1% who isn't so possesive over Syaoran, and wants him to be with Sakura only, copy and paste this into your sig.

Offline Robin Sena

  • Now with 100% more fads!
  • "Die-Hard Fan!"
  • *****
  • Posts: 1,679
  • BOING!
Re: The heresy that is Cardcaptors.
« Reply #317 on: May 08 2005, 04:55 pm »
I don't know the main script of CC.

Did the two really said those?

Well, YOU JUST HAVE TO TALK!
click!
Fanfic - CLAMP in Gradius World (Fanfic Done! 26 Chapters)<br />Next Fanfic - Monster Hunter Diaries *NEW!*
Story of Infinite Possibilities - Blocks Made. Block 1 - Fate (Fate, Testament, Eternity) Block 2 - Infinity (Infinity, Memento, Betrayal) Block 3 - World Order (World Order, Metempsychosis, Damnation) Special Edition - 155 cards made<br />Next Block! - Kaleido Dreams! (Kaleido Dreams, Angelic Voices, Snow Sunlight)<br />
Nirvana TEST BLOCK!

Offline D.J.P

  • Sakura is Mine!!
  • Administrator
  • > Supa-Dupa Fan! <
  • *****
  • Posts: 5,838
  • Gender: Male
Re: The heresy that is Cardcaptors.
« Reply #318 on: May 08 2005, 05:12 pm »
Off my head I can't say when Sakura talked about 360's

as for the website comment that was the sword card episode (at the end), don't remember specifcs been a fair while since I've seen that episode
-- 'Expect the unexpected' -- Keroberos (Cardcaptor Sakura) --
-- To err is human; to really foul things up takes a computer. --
Robin Sena's Card Sets: Download Here (Last Updated: 12th May 2006 10.10PM AEST)
------------------------------------------------
I host this domain, be nice :) and Read the Forum Rules!
Avatar made by Sofiacardcaptors. Signature image by Bluetopaz
 My WoW Characters | Support CapturedWings.net | Web-Hosting Now Available

Offline Robin Sena

  • Now with 100% more fads!
  • "Die-Hard Fan!"
  • *****
  • Posts: 1,679
  • BOING!
Re: The heresy that is Cardcaptors.
« Reply #319 on: May 08 2005, 05:40 pm »
Did Tomoyo refer anything about the website in the CCS version? (CC and CCS)

Well, YOU JUST HAVE TO TALK!
click!
Fanfic - CLAMP in Gradius World (Fanfic Done! 26 Chapters)<br />Next Fanfic - Monster Hunter Diaries *NEW!*
Story of Infinite Possibilities - Blocks Made. Block 1 - Fate (Fate, Testament, Eternity) Block 2 - Infinity (Infinity, Memento, Betrayal) Block 3 - World Order (World Order, Metempsychosis, Damnation) Special Edition - 155 cards made<br />Next Block! - Kaleido Dreams! (Kaleido Dreams, Angelic Voices, Snow Sunlight)<br />
Nirvana TEST BLOCK!