CLAMP's Famous Works > Tsubasa RESERVoir CHRoNiCLE
Better seiyuu for Sakura
LemonPing:
i'd pick tange sakura... i think there are still many other seiyuu tat can sound better than makino yui... i dunno who but im sure there is...
Cherry tiger:
--- Quote from: Kurorin on June 09 2005, 01:00 am ---I don't think it's a fair comparison. Sakura from CCS is not the same character from Tsubasa. It's not just that their ages (CCS Sakura was much younger), but the direction the story is going. Also, there could be so many factors that determine why Makino Yui "acts" like that. The director could be deliberately telling her to speak not too confidently because that's what's appropriate for the character.
--- End quote ---
Very good observation. Thanks for pointing it out. But to me, I was looking at it pretty much in general (Yeah, I did sound a little too judgemental didn't I? Sorry!) Since I'm seeing it as this 'Who really sounds like Sakura'.
bLuetopaz:
i voted Tange Sakura...
like Sakaki said.. she IS Sakura to me.. hehe..
Kurorin:
--- Quote from: Cherry tiger on June 09 2005, 02:47 am ---But to me, I was looking at it pretty much in general (Yeah, I did sound a little too judgemental didn't I? Sorry!) Since I'm seeing it as this 'Who really sounds like Sakura'.
--- End quote ---
You don't need to apologize for your opinion :) I totally understood what you meant, but I was also trying to be fair to both seiyuu. Personally, I would have also wanted to hear Sakura Tange reprise her role, but for whatever reason, Makino Yui got the part.
Sya0ran:
Sakura Tange's voice is magnificent as Sakura and so is Makino Yui. Either one fits...but I really don't think we should compare the seiyuu's for TRC right now because sooner or later TRC is gonna get licensed and just imagine the horror of the dubbed voices. @.@;
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version