Poll

Who's the better seiyuu for Sakura?

Tange Sakura
6 (60%)
Yui Makino
4 (40%)

Total Members Voted: 10

« previous next »
Pages: [1] 2 3

AuthorTopic: Better seiyuu for Sakura  (Read 10738 times)

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline Cherry tiger

  • Supporter of C!S+S
  • Obsessed Fan
  • ***
  • Posts: 427
  • Gender: Female
  • I cannot fathom it, honestly...
Better seiyuu for Sakura
« on: June 08 2005, 04:15 pm »
I've realised in this board that there are some who like Tange Sakura and some who don't. And then there are some who like Sakura's new seiyuu... and some who don't.

So make your pick and let's see which is the most favoured seiyuu.

Me? I'm going with Tange Sakura. She may be squeeky and high-pitched, but it's Sakura... she made Sakura stand out among the lot. She made Sakura unique...

Not to say that Yui Makino's really bad or anything. She's good (although a little bit inexperienced) but I suppose Tange Sakura made a great impression on me on Sakura. Meh... so what do you guys think?
Logged


cute little sis:Goku[cardcaptors_ria]
cousin: yume-chan

Need singers to sing my english version of any songs! Check out this blog to see the list of songs you can sing from and please contact me if you're interested! Thanks!

My fanfictions@My Music Videos (on Youtube)@My Myspace@My LJ

Offline Sakaki

  • "Die-Hard Fan!"
  • *****
  • Posts: 1,563
  • Gender: Female
Re: Better seiyuu for Sakura
« Reply #1 on: June 08 2005, 04:26 pm »
Sakura Tange just IS Sakura to me.
The first time I watched Cardcaptor Sakura I was amazed with her voice.
It was SO different than anything I had heard from an English speaking voice actor.
I guess that's why I can't watch dubs, I've gotten used to the Japanese Seiyuu and expect more than a U.S. voice actor is capable of.

I also love the new Sakura.
I think her voice is very pleasant and sounds like an older Sakura.
I think she's doing very well for all that she has to live up to coming after Sakura Tange.
Logged

Offline .::ka::.

  • "HUmp!" like Kuro-tan XD
  • Mega Fan
  • ***
  • Posts: 256
  • Gender: Female
  • HUmp ?!
Re: Better seiyuu for Sakura
« Reply #2 on: June 08 2005, 08:49 pm »
Both are suit to me ^________^ But i will pick Yui Makino because noone pick her :D
Somes say that the new seiyu of Sakura is annoying, but I don't think so... She do great with it :D
Logged
- Starting from here - Let's make a promise - You and me - Let's just be honest -
Kurogane is <3

My Precious <~ down for a while >___>  | My Journal
Forum Family
My lovely little sis XD Kai Mizuki [/i] & Aya-chan[/i]

Offline Ken-Chan

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 12
  • Gender: Male
  • Personal text here! Edit this on your profile page
Re: Better seiyuu for Sakura
« Reply #3 on: June 08 2005, 11:06 pm »
anyway i did not even realise there is a change in it until someone told me,which episode did they change and who is the first seiyuu and who is the second
Logged

Offline Kurorin

  • New Fan
  • *
  • Posts: 55
  • Gender: Female
  • Personal text here! Edit this on your profile page
Re: Better seiyuu for Sakura
« Reply #4 on: June 09 2005, 01:00 am »
I don't think it's a fair comparison. Sakura from CCS is not the same character from Tsubasa.  It's not just that their ages (CCS Sakura was much younger), but the direction the story is going.  Also, there could be so many factors that determine why Makino Yui "acts" like that.  The director could be deliberately telling her to speak not too confidently because that's what's appropriate for the character.
Logged
Webmaster, Wing Journey

Offline LemonPing

  • Good Fan
  • **
  • Posts: 130
  • Gender: Female
  • This is Kobato-chan from CLAMP's Kobato(Temporary)
Re: Better seiyuu for Sakura
« Reply #5 on: June 09 2005, 01:09 am »
i'd pick tange sakura... i think there are still many other seiyuu tat can sound better than makino yui... i dunno who but im sure there is...
Logged

Offline Cherry tiger

  • Supporter of C!S+S
  • Obsessed Fan
  • ***
  • Posts: 427
  • Gender: Female
  • I cannot fathom it, honestly...
Re: Better seiyuu for Sakura
« Reply #6 on: June 09 2005, 02:47 am »
Quote from: Kurorin on June 09 2005, 01:00 am
I don't think it's a fair comparison. Sakura from CCS is not the same character from Tsubasa. It's not just that their ages (CCS Sakura was much younger), but the direction the story is going. Also, there could be so many factors that determine why Makino Yui "acts" like that. The director could be deliberately telling her to speak not too confidently because that's what's appropriate for the character.

Very good observation. Thanks for pointing it out. But to me, I was looking at it pretty much in general (Yeah, I did sound a little too judgemental didn't I? Sorry!) Since I'm seeing it as this 'Who really sounds like Sakura'.
Logged


cute little sis:Goku[cardcaptors_ria]
cousin: yume-chan

Need singers to sing my english version of any songs! Check out this blog to see the list of songs you can sing from and please contact me if you're interested! Thanks!

My fanfictions@My Music Videos (on Youtube)@My Myspace@My LJ

Offline bLuetopaz

  • .::the illuminating heart::.
  • "Die-Hard Fan!"
  • *****
  • Posts: 1,749
  • Gender: Female
  • Personal text here! Edit this on your profile page
Re: Better seiyuu for Sakura
« Reply #7 on: June 09 2005, 05:27 am »
i voted Tange Sakura...

like Sakaki said.. she IS Sakura to me.. hehe..
Logged


Forum Family:
Little bro: Tooya_Mizuki
Little sis: fisah :: lika-chi :: Starfire :: sofiacardcaptors :: Angelic-Essence :: Ruby Chan :: -=kuro_woof=- :: cardcaptors_ria :: Fai :: babypigggy :: .HACk//kite//shUgO
Cousin: Ralea :: CherryandWolfLover :: Zeldi :: yume-chan
---

Offline Kurorin

  • New Fan
  • *
  • Posts: 55
  • Gender: Female
  • Personal text here! Edit this on your profile page
Re: Better seiyuu for Sakura
« Reply #8 on: June 09 2005, 06:33 am »
Quote from: Cherry tiger on June 09 2005, 02:47 am
But to me, I was looking at it pretty much in general (Yeah, I did sound a little too judgemental didn't I? Sorry!) Since I'm seeing it as this 'Who really sounds like Sakura'.

You don't need to apologize for your opinion :)  I totally understood what you meant, but I was also trying to be fair to both seiyuu.  Personally, I would have also wanted to hear Sakura Tange reprise her role, but for whatever reason, Makino Yui got the part.
Logged
Webmaster, Wing Journey

Offline Sya0ran

  • :: You're my Paradise ::
  • "Exceptional Fan"
  • *****
  • Posts: 1,299
  • Gender: Female
  • I love Syaoran!<3
Re: Better seiyuu for Sakura
« Reply #9 on: June 09 2005, 06:40 am »
Sakura Tange's voice is magnificent as Sakura and so is Makino Yui.  Either one fits...but I really don't think we should compare the seiyuu's for TRC right now because sooner or later TRC is gonna get licensed and just imagine the horror of the dubbed voices.  @.@;
Logged
"I am totally happy and not dangerous mostly."

Forum Family
Little Sis:  Babypigggy <3

Zephora.Net | Amourae.Com | TRC Fansite | SasuSaku Shrine | Myspace | Fanfics

Offline Airi

  • ~Doki Doki~
  • Good Fan
  • **
  • Posts: 120
  • Gender: Female
Re: Better seiyuu for Sakura
« Reply #10 on: June 09 2005, 09:58 am »
I'm voting for Sakura Tange, Yui Horie, or Ayako Kawasumi that would fit for Sakura's voice ^^
Logged

Offline Brad

  • Big Fan
  • **
  • Posts: 191
  • Gender: Male
  • Puu!
Re: Better seiyuu for Sakura
« Reply #11 on: June 17 2005, 11:30 pm »
Tange Sakura all the way. I'm not saying so because she's a better actress, but the new gal just annoys the Hell out of me! Her first line in the first episode almost made me change chanels (seriously, it's just really annoying!)
Logged
Swing by my two babies, Loop: TRC & Link: xxxHolic

Offline scarecrow_wingz

  • Super Fan
  • ***
  • Posts: 342
  • Gender: Female
Re: Better seiyuu for Sakura
« Reply #12 on: June 19 2005, 12:48 am »
it really depends. tange sakura is perfect for 10yo sakura...

but actually...i think yui makino acts really weakly for tsubasa
Logged
~when you have eliminated the impossible, whatever remains, however improbable, must be the truth - Sherlock Holmes
~you are not what you are born, but what you choose to become - Professor Dumbledore

Offline Kyle Rondart

  • New Fan
  • *
  • Posts: 66
  • Gender: Male
  • Personal text here! Edit this on your profile page.
Re: Better seiyuu for Sakura
« Reply #13 on: June 19 2005, 05:32 am »
I voted for Yui Makino cuz she's new & she can really sing too. Another reason I voted for her is cuz Sakura Tange has no voice range at all.
Logged

Offline Little Star

  • Good Fan
  • **
  • Posts: 111
  • Gender: Female
  • I should smile? that's exactly what I do
Re: Better seiyuu for Sakura
« Reply #14 on: June 19 2005, 09:05 am »
So, I don't think that is a good comparisson...Sakura Tange did to little Sakura in ccs
Logged

.::Sakura No Yokan::.    .::Lost Tsubasa Web::.  
I should smile? that's exactly what I do   ---free butterfly ...    Thnks for the cookie ^^ I'm very happy

Offline Brad

  • Big Fan
  • **
  • Posts: 191
  • Gender: Male
  • Puu!
Re: Better seiyuu for Sakura
« Reply #15 on: June 19 2005, 09:58 am »
But the thing is the Tsubasa Sakura is still speaking like a 10 year old! I'm guessing the Tsubasa Sakura is around 15-17. If the voice was dramatically different like, say,  a real teenager voice, then this would be a strange argument.
Logged
Swing by my two babies, Loop: TRC & Link: xxxHolic

Offline Kyle Rondart

  • New Fan
  • *
  • Posts: 66
  • Gender: Male
  • Personal text here! Edit this on your profile page.
Re: Better seiyuu for Sakura
« Reply #16 on: June 19 2005, 12:22 pm »
I did some research & it seems that Yui Makino was a stage actress before she was a seiyuu. That might be part of the reason some of you feel she can't act that well. She's a teenage stage actress. On top of that she's worked with Yoko Kanna like Maaya Sakamoto.
Logged

Offline cloud

  • "A True Fan"
  • *****
  • Posts: 1,043
  • Gender: Female
Re: Better seiyuu for Sakura
« Reply #17 on: June 22 2005, 03:29 am »
tange sakura all the way.
Logged

Offline Cherry tiger

  • Supporter of C!S+S
  • Obsessed Fan
  • ***
  • Posts: 427
  • Gender: Female
  • I cannot fathom it, honestly...
Re: Better seiyuu for Sakura
« Reply #18 on: June 22 2005, 11:29 am »
I kinda agree that Yui Makino will be able to sing really well. (Heard she's going to sing for the movie? @.@) But I really liked Tange Sakura's voice... When she sings, I can really imagine Sakura singing. I don't think her singing range is limited. Have you ever heard 'Release my heart'? I thought she sang really well there.
Logged


cute little sis:Goku[cardcaptors_ria]
cousin: yume-chan

Need singers to sing my english version of any songs! Check out this blog to see the list of songs you can sing from and please contact me if you're interested! Thanks!

My fanfictions@My Music Videos (on Youtube)@My Myspace@My LJ

Offline Kyle Rondart

  • New Fan
  • *
  • Posts: 66
  • Gender: Male
  • Personal text here! Edit this on your profile page.
Re: Better seiyuu for Sakura
« Reply #19 on: June 22 2005, 11:31 am »
Yui Makino sings Omna Magni from Sousei no Aquarion. Really cute song with lots of Latin.
Logged
Pages: [1] 2 3
« previous next »