CapturedWings.org Forums
CLAMP's Famous Works => Tsubasa RESERVoir CHRoNiCLE => Topic started by: Ruby Chan on April 15 2005, 06:51 am
-
So, which is better? The TRC anime, or the manga?
-
-^^- It really isn't fair to ask that question untill we have seen more of the anime, don't ya think?
-
I enjoyed both but if I had to pick....the anime, I loved the animation and the seiyuu a lot. But the manga will always be adorable because it's CLAMP.
-
The anime is great because of the joy of seeing everything in motion with BGM. The manga is much better tho~ because it's the original :sweatdrop:
-
Yeah, probably anime. It's nice to hear BGMs.
-
The anime is great because of the joy of seeing everything in motion with BGM. The manga is much better tho~ because it's the original :sweatdrop:
i agree. the manga just has more life to it. i know that's kinda crazy to say when you have the anime that's actually in motion. but eh. :D love the manga
-
Manga for me... because it's the originally from CLAMP. Most animes tend to veer off from the manga after a period of time... @.@
But I still like the anime for the music. :keke:
-
I suggest the comic :D Well, maybe the comic has adorable artwork, and also in the anime series it skipped some of the details, whereas in the comic, it just sounds....clearer. I think the reason why I don't prefer the anime more, it just I think maybe NHK hasn't done such a superb job, that I was a little bit disappointed (the ending was ...funny....reminded me of GSD :P). Maybe...its just that I haven't seen enough of it....
-
i really like the anime and manga... they both are similar... it's like a fanfic that's similar.. but some parts are changed just to see what will happen if something else happened instead of that... get what i mean? kinda like writing a fanfic.. you want this to happen.. but what'll happen if this happens instead?
-
You're right... Even if the plot in the anime were to change a little bit, it might be even more interesting. Kinda like 'Full Moon wo Sagashite', both the anime and manga are totally different but the same plot, so I think Tsubasa might be capable of pulling the same thing off... but that depends on how good Bee-Train is.
-
I love both ^^ :D Because it's a work for S&S :D I love them :D
-
Love them both!! but... Manga is BETTER... coz they r drawn by Clamp themselves :P
and.. they change some stuffs in the anime... say the part that the castle guards were looking for sakura.. and syaoran took her to run away.... errr.. tat's a bit off.. i think..coz syaoran is supposed to be the shy one... err i think... at least the quiter one...
but still love it though... soo much Sakura n Syaoran moments :P
-
oh yea.. somehow i like the manga better too.. cause the art looks better! :D and.............. the anime doesn't make them as good looking! :\
-
I agree with Bao_Nhia_Yang - the artwork in the manga is way better. Plus, I feel closer to the characters than I do in the anime...somehow they seem less vibrant, despite the excellent voice actors and music.
-
I agree with Bao_Nhia_Yang - the artwork in the manga is way better. Plus, I feel closer to the characters than I do in the anime...somehow they seem less vibrant, despite the excellent voice actors and music.
I feel the same way about the anime. I'm closer to the characters in the manga than in the anime. I just can't seem to relate with the anime that much......
-
Plus, there isn't any passion. When Sakura was getting captured and enchanted and stuff in the first episode, Syaoran seemed to just be there. He didn't seem as frantic as in the manga.
-
Plus, there isn't any passion. When Sakura was getting captured and enchanted and stuff in the first episode, Syaoran seemed to just be there. He didn't seem as frantic as in the manga.
Ya exactly! I was really mad about that. It appeared as if he didn't care all that much... Oh well, I guess Bee-Train was too lazy to show him panicked :dodge:
-
The next episodes better be better....or I'm gonna hav to give up on the series and stick to the manga.
-
:lol: I'll continue watching it for the sake of it, but of course I'll always love the manga more :wink:
-
i can do both.. and i will stick to both! ^-^ i can say that the anime is awkward... seems like he's running more than what's needed.. and jumping longer than how close he is to sakura.
-
I'm gonna keep trying....but I can't stand watching animes that mangle mangas!
-
i guess both the anime and manga has their own side to which is better...
(hey ruby-chan.. i can't personal message you!)
-
Ummm...how about now?
-
I think there will be pros and cons in both the manga and anime, and to say that we don't feel close to the characters in the anime... somehow I don't feel it's right to judge just yet. We've only watched one episode (two for most of you who has more time to download than me... ^^) so I think it's too early to relate to the characters just yet. (It took a while for me in the manga as well... they just... grow on you sooner or later.)
-
I like the manga better because... I don't know (I hate answering the question of 'WHY???') I just do! (It is the original, I suppose?)
The anime is addicting because of the music.... I definately want the soundtrack more than the actual anime, lol!
-
I think I would choose both...manga is good to take with you when traveling and anime is just GREAT! XD Also not to mention the animation and music.
-
I.. I... I have to say manga! O.O and that's a first! xD I'm always a devoted anime fan xD but this was the firts manga I read before watching its anime!!!! so i'm fond with the original concept :P though it is nice to have an anime to watch and love... the music was great... I want Fai's song!!! xD (i want him to have one xD)
-
Too hard too choose! Obssesed in both :sweatdrop:.
-
Um, for me, manga is always first priority. Why? Well, anime is always based off the manga, and although its entertaining to watch, it was originally based off the manga, which I think has the more original, thorough plot and ideas. Plus, we are paying for their artwork. Also, manga is much more affordable compared to original anime -- unless its bootlegs, in which I hate, cause it doesn't support the artists.
Secondly, look at Tsubasa Chronicle, sure its great it got turned into an anime, but its only got 26 episodes while the manga is still ongoing. Plus, they didn't explain a lot of stuff, and some of the characters drawn/personalities are horrid. Yes, its great. But manga...better =^^=
-
i prefer the anime.. short and easy to 'digest' though i will miss out a lot of stuffs from the manga! *boo*
-
i havent seen the anime yet and was looking for a way to see it! you know where i can get it?
-
You need it in bittorent or wmv?
-
I prefer the manga albeit I do love and adore the anime a lot. The manga just seems more orginal and if I were to ever fall in love with the anime (besides all the upcoming kawaii scenes of S+S together) it would only be for the music. I simply love the music. :inlove:
Lol. Anyway, weve all only seen like 2 episodes or so and there are more coming so we shouldn't really choose which one we like best right now. Its far to early to decide. :keke:
-
I appreciate the manga more than the anime, because i can have the story in the hand, and i don,t know, it seems, to me, original to read the manga because i love to know a story when i read it^-^
-
i havent seen the anime yet and was looking for a way to see it! you know where i can get it?
Little Wolf has a thread with the epsodes for download here...
http://www.capturedwings.net/forums/index.php?topic=128.0
-
depends on personal taste so i go for anime
-
Manga ( That way I can take *Fai* Tsubasa with me where ever I go!)
But It's nice to see the anime too because of the music
-
@_@ mmmm both T_T it's difficult sorry o_o i like both.. manga it's interesting and the anime it's great! >.<
-
i prefer the manga cause syaoran looks mooore cute ^-^, atractive(grrr), and well drawn (no offence...), well its just better the syaoran-manga than the syaoran-anime(but i like the syaoran anime too, hehe)
-
well not only syaoran but also all characters and stuff (...)
-
For the longest time I loved the manga because they go into depth on everything, and the anime was lacking alot from the anime, but lately, the episodes have taken a different turn from the original manga, and adding things that weren't in the manga. So if your asking me if I like them recently I would say both, but if you ask overall from the last 6 months I would say manga.
-
Well, I personally prefer the manga.
-
I should say both. The manga is more fast paced and better plotted and all, but I love the anime's music and animation.
-
Manga without much thinking. Though the anime has it´s good points such as music, songs and listening to how your favorite characters would sound ^^
-
I like both the anime and manga, but if I had to choose then it would be definitely the Manga because I thought the Anime was abit rushed and besides, I am more of a Manga person.
-
I say manga cause I don't really see much of the anime. >_< The anime is still awesome though. ^^
-
I like the manga best. I've seen a few episodes of Tsubasa but I still have to see the rest. I might change my mind when i see the whole anime but for now im sticking with the manga. aahh.. Syaoran oh how much i wish he was mine... :cry:
-
Puh~ difficult xD
I like both...
-
I like the expressions in the manga. and the drunk scenes! but the music in the anime is sooo good!
oh, i know! reading the manga, whilst listening to the OST! that would be perfect!
-
Anime or manga...
Well, that's a tricky one... Mostly I'd choose for the manga, because that's the exact way the creators wanted it to be. But I also really like the TRC anime, because the style, story, music and all match the manga quite well (I've seen worse, let's say that). Still, I think I'd say the manga, because it just has that x-factor or whatever they call it ^_^
-
I like the expressions in the manga. and the drunk scenes! but the music in the anime is sooo good!
oh, i know! reading the manga, whilst listening to the OST! that would be perfect!
Yeah!!! Meowzy-sama you're sooo right!!! That's the best! XD
-
Where do u download the manga???
-
I love both. I can't choose between the two. I'm hoping that within the two years that Tsubasa Chronicles is going to run, that it can be somewhat depth. It's probably hard to fit everything into a 30 minute lenght and thats why it's not exactly "in-depth". Yet, for what it's worth, I'd say it's pretty damn well-done. No anime follows it's manga conterpart exactly.
Anyway, both. ^^;
-
definitely the manga....it's so much funnier, the mood is lighter, the art is better (the anime is way too plain, even for an animation....) and the story is just done better.
Really the only redeeming quality of the anime is the music.....which is awesome.
But I watch it because I must uphold my title of being someone who has seen every animation to every CLAMP title out there, lol.
-
HI!
I have to say the manga. Is so much better. And the art work is great.
I don't know if it's just me. But the manga is like full of live and the anime is like... I don't know how to put it. The manga is better.
But I have to give some credit to the anime it's a good work, but if you ask me not my favorite anime in the art part.
Well that is my opinion. BYE...
-
I say manga =\ i dont know why..but i think the animations a bit plain >.<
-
I love the music and it's cool to see everything in color and all.... But for me it's not even a hard decision. I LOVE the manga. CLAMP's art is so beautiful, I just don't think anime could ever live up to it. They have a style (especially in TRC) that lends itself to still drawings much better than moving ones. I love them both! :keke:
-
Both, actually. I love the music in the anime and the art itself (though it wasn't as good in the beginning as it became later) but I'm very much addicted to the manga... I think I'd pick the manga, because that was what CLAMP created itself and the anime contains very many scenes that were not in the manga.
-
I have to say manga because I've never seen the anime.
-
After the last few episodes which were really good I must say both not only the manga... but Clamps stile is the best! No question about that!
-
Manga XD Not being a Clamp fanbrat, but the manga was definetly a little better than the anime, probably because you feel more attached to the characters, and I also love the art, the humourous/romance scenes, not to mention the art XD
Wait I said that already ^^;
-
I like manga version more than anime (Oh I hate anime but still I watch it XD)
In anime there is music..
In manga you can dream/imagination some acts better than anime.
-
i say... anime because for manga, I have only read the 1st book... Mangas sold here are damn expensive!! If you want the original manga that is translated to english cost about RM39.90 (per book!!) There is the chinese version that is cheaper of course... but I can't read chinese!!! ='(
-
I would say both Equally. I've seen the anime which has come out which is totaly alsome . I just love the music. I've read all the manga out in english thus far, and so far the anime has followed very well with the manga. With the exception of the ending of the first season which I have no clue about but it's anime and needed to end someplace on a high note I guess. Can't wait for more of the anime and the manga to come out though.
-
I would have to say Anime.
I think its better than the manga
-
I prefer manga over anime.
I'm more manga, than anime, person in general, that may affect my decicion too.
Anime has mainly two things I like about it:
1) those mostly awesome BGMs.
2) Fai in the intro (what? I love how he moves in it when fightin' >D It's so againts all anatomy, I think, but still so cool, lol. )
But still, I gotta see rest of the episodes some day (I have currently 17).
-
I like the manga better as well because the anime is really making everything a drag. Nevertheless, I like the anime as well. But I think the manga is better for TRC =)
-
I totaly agree the manga is som much better
-
I prefer the manga. The anime is nice and all especially coz of the music but I think the manga's drawn better (there aren't any blushes in the anime! -- my friend pointed this out to me) and I just prefer the manga better. Besides, Yuko looks weird in the anime @.@
~Syv
-
I really prefer manga :noteworthy: :noteworthy: :noteworthy: :noteworthy: :noteworthy: :noteworthy: :noteworthy: :noteworthy: :noteworthy: :noteworthy: :noteworthy: :noteworthy: :noteworthy:, but sometimes I preffer anime. Drawing is better in manga than in anime (sometimes syaoran's eyes are too big or they're a bit separates... :hmp:)
-
:okay: I prefer manga best and it's because the drawings are much more better than the anime, and the story it's a little different. It doesn't changes, but in the manga the story is more clear and they explain every fact in the story....mmm....but the anime is cool also...they just need more good drawings and more fighting!!!  :wink:
-
I prefer the manga. The anime is nice and all especially coz of the music but I think the manga's drawn better (there aren't any blushes in the anime! -- my friend pointed this out to me) and I just prefer the manga better. Besides, Yuko looks weird in the anime @.@
~Syv
there are blushes in the anime but they are rare and you need to look real carefully